Twilight Movie Review

November 22nd, 2008 at 12:05 am by Kaleb Nation

This review contains minimal spoilers.

I am going to be very honest in my review of Twilight. Thus, it should first be known that I went to see the film not expecting to be overly thrilled.

We have been waiting on this movie for months. People have scoured the internet and fansites for every photo, soundtrack clip and interview there is. There are t-shirts and perfumes and merchandise for this movie long before it is even out, or anyone has seen it, or anyone has even had a chance to decide if they like it. The fact is that it has been so hyped, it almost seemed as if there was no possible way it could live up to the expectations that I and thousands of other fans had.

But then, it did.

Bella and Edward

Bella and Edward

The moment that the opening titles of the film appeared, I was transported to the world that Stephenie had created. I don’t know exactly how it happened: whether it was hearing Bella’s voice, or the words we all know so well from the prologue. But I suddenly felt this was the film that I, and thousands of others, had been waiting on for months. This was Twilight, and it was finally here.

The details of the movie will speak for themselves when you see it (hopefully, more than once). But I will say that everything from the book is there: from meeting Edward in the school, to Edward saving Bella in the alley, to the trip to La Push, to running from James, to the prom scene. Everything is there — and even more. As I watched the movie, I felt an urge to call my friends still waiting for midnight in a different time zone, and tell them to brace themselves for what they were about to see.

I certainly did not go into the theater expecting to laugh while watching the film. There are a few laughs in the book, but I thought the movie would be a strict romance and leave no room for embellishment. But Charlie, Jasper, Mike Newton, and Eric Yorkie made everyone in the theater laugh endlessly. Michael Welch was a wonderful actor, and made his character leap right out from the books. I can easily see Catherine Hardwicke’s influence in keeping the film from being overly serious business, and yet delicately keeping with the plot of the story.

The sparkling was everything I had expected it to be. The meadow was just as I had pictured it. Vampire baseball was exactly as I had imagined: with the added effect of the perfect music selection in the background (you’ll recognize it when you hear it).

The Cullens in the baseball scene

The Cullens in the baseball scene

All of the vampire action was amazing. It is impossible to put to words the feeling you get when you see Bella trapped in the alley, and then see Edward suddenly roar in with his shiny silver Volvo. Robert Pattinson was able to portray Edward so well: I could feel how angry he was, and how close he came to killing them.

There was of course some awkwardness along the way. The flying Edward didn’t quite click with me. Bella seemed to fall for Edward very quickly, despite what her outside feelings seemed to portray. But each of these were so minor they were hardly noticeable.

As for any doubts on the soundtrack, they have all been wiped away. I didn’t get a few of the song selections when I first heard the album, but when you actually see the film and where each song is placed, it is far easier to understand. And, for any doubters still out there, Bella’s Lullaby sounds far better when it is seen in the movie.

It would really be impossible to pick a favorite scene without spoiling it for those who haven’t read it. So, I have prepared my three favorite scenes in only 2 words, so people who have seen the movie will know what I’m talking about, and those who haven’t will not:

Three favorite scenes:

1. Edward… alley

2. Cullens… baseball

3. Edward… piano.

And my three favorite funny scenes:

1. Mike… window (ha ha)

2. Jasper… sniff (he he)

3. Charlie… gun (BAHAHA)

Also, there was a whole lot of pointing and whispering when it came to the scene with Stephenie. She was typing at a computer — hopefully, working on another book.

Of course, people have already started to complain that the movie doesn’t follow the books — but they are vastly wrong. This is one of the most loyal films I have seen before. Unlike many book-to-films, you can actually tell that this is based upon the novel — every major event in Twilight is covered, in nearly the same exact order in the books.

Bella And Edward at Prom

Bella And Edward at Prom

The thing to keep in mind is that it is very hard to transpose a novel onto the screen, since they are two entirely different mediums. Tiny details like Bella having an iPod or the exact dialogue are simply details that have to be shifted into film. It is very much like translating from English to Latin, where certain words must be moved and rearranged to make it understandable.

I was particularly surprised that the movie turned out so wonderfully on such a small budget. This definitely attests to Catherine Hardwicke’s directing, as she was able to create a studio-quality film with nearly $100 million less than the first Harry Potter.

Any doubts that I had of this film being a success have vanished. So congratulations to Stephenie, and Catherine, and everyone else who was involved in the making of this movie. Twilight was worth the wait.

For the comments: What did you think of the Twilight movie?! What were your favorite parts? (people who haven’t seen it, be warned: spoilers will be in the comments!)

NOTE: Huge news! TwilightGuy.com just passed TWO MILLION HITS!

Bookmark and Share

Posted in Twilight Movie

Related Posts:

Twilight Movie Trailer
New Moon Will Be A Movie
  • I loved the movie! I wasn't sure where parts of the soundtrack were going to fit in, but when I heard them it went perfectly with the scenes. I didn't expect to laugh as much as I did, either. Mike in the window was hilarious! And Emmett and the knife! I fell in love with the baseball scene even more. The kiss was crazy, I almost fell out of my chair, I was freaking out so much. The actors portrayed their characters perfectly, and I'm going to watch it again with my friends tomorrow. :D
  • Bethany
    Overall I thought it was a great piece of eye candy and a great representation of the book. However, there were a couple times that the editing was downright painful. The cut scenes and closeups in the biology class? Billy's face in the truck? Campy. I loved everything about the ballet studio scene, though, especially the montage after Bella was bitten. And I agree with the funny parts you mentioned! I'm just afraid that was it was so highly stylized that it will be impossible to shift into a sequel. It felt very much like a stand-alone piece to me, regardless of the ending.
  • Jessica
    It was amazing! Ha, I got 3 hours of sleep last night... but it was definitely worth it! I had doubts about many of the cast choices but everyone worked out perfectly. I especially loved Jasper; whenever you saw him he really did look like he was in pain and we just starting cracking up. I'm already planning more trips to to the theater!
  • layna cullen
    (First?)That was a great review, Kaleb! I really appreciated it. I agreed with everything you said. I absolutely loved the movie and I felt like they did a fantastic job of staying true to the book, while still making an adaptation that of course couldn't include every detail.

    In addition to the funny scenes you listed, i laughed really hard when Edward and Bella walk into school together and Bella says that everyone is staring, and Edward says something like "No, that guy isn't. Oh never mind, he just did!" I think it just sounded hilarious the way Rob/Edward's amazing voice sounds :)

    I was also so impressed with everyone's acting! You're right, Rob did such an AMAZING job with the looks of pain, like when he was saying good bye to Bella when she was in the car and in the ballet scene.

    I'm glad you liked it!
  • layna cullen
    oh never mind- not first- fourth! oh well :)
  • Jessica
    Hrm. I actually thought they did a good job with Victoria at the end and that it set up the desire for a sequel without leaving you unsatisfied. When the credits came up I wanted to start chanting "New Moon, New Moon!"
  • Aria
    I went to a midnight showing at a theater not ten minutes from amajor high school... there was a lot of screaming... So I'm not sure I got the full effect. But I did like what I saw, for the most part. it seemed to trip forward a lot. Like it was a little rushed, but that may have been due to my fingers firmly in my ears for the first 45 minutes.

    I loved the field trip, the make out cause of my shock at Bella's short shorts, and of course the scene in which they meet cause that reaction had the whole theater laughing.
  • Bethany
    oh, and I also thought that Edward wasn't so much the character from the book as he was Rob's interpretation of him, which is okay. I was just a little surprised. it seemed like he was channeling Edward Scissorhands a little in the biology class, though.
  • Alyssa
    Like you, I didn't go in with the highest expectations (rather expected to be disappointed) and I think that really paid off. I totally agree that when the voice over prologue started (which I really thought was going to be left out) I was so happy and got me really excited to see how the rest would be,
    Yeah, there were some cheesy parts that made me groan and put my head in my hands, but none of that mattered because everything was just so spot-on.
    The music was amazing, as was the cinematography. Some of my friends didn't like the shaky/intimate camera shots, but I liked the effects they created.
    I was so happy with how the actors portrayed their characters. You could really tell they understood the inner workings of their characters.
    I can't wait to see it again!
    ps. Alice in the ballet studio? SO bad ass!!!
  • Tia
    I have watched it twice already and I love it. I was astonished at how well Kristen Stewart acted. I was on the fence about her, but she is Bella, just as Robert is Edward. I loved the wings behind Edward in the biology class and I loved Mike and Eric. It had so many funny parts...I loved Jessica...and the scene at the prom where Bella was motioning about Jessica's dress being cut so low.

    I also went in with low expectations and I just don't see how it has gotten such a bad rating on rottentomatoes. Last time I checked it was at 43%.
  • Krystol
    I loved the movie! I went and saw it at midnight too and my only complaints were the stupid teen girls screaming every time Rob came on screen. I just wanted to stand up and yell "Shut up!" Gah... anyway.

    I'm so glad someone else shared my opinion, I have heard nothing but complaints from so many of the "fans" that it is starting to make me mad. It's like Breaking Dawn and that "other" book all over again (yes, I know what the book is called but SM doesn't want to hear those two words for a long time). The movie was incredible on such a small budget, I was very impressed and I plan to see it many more times.
  • meg
    I saw the movie, but i missed about half of it. Why? Because the crazed loonies in the theater wouldn't shut up, or turn off their cellfones for a moment. ill try to see it again without the distractions. what i did see was pretty frickin awesome tho!
  • noodle
    I saw it today and i have to confess... i have a pretty mixed opinion about it.

    Yes, The movies is faithful to the book, but i felt that the story was so damn fast in the first hour and, in the second hour was ok. Also some parts (actually chapters on the book) were narrated in 3 o 4 minutes. i didn't enjoyed that.

    I really love the baseball and dance escene and the funny parts, i didn't expected them!


    About the music, i was SURPRISED with the last song! 15 steps by Radiohead... that was a good one! it was... ORGASMIC!
  • Jen
    I also didn't have very high expectations going into it..don't get me wrong, I was uber excited for it..but thinking realistically, I didn't want to be disappointed! And it was a zillion times better than I hoped! The best part for me was how the actors all got the characters from the book right on!
    I loved Charlie's humor and Jasper's facial exppressions were gold! haha I am still laghing about it!
    I will be seeing it again on Sunday, can't wait!
  • @Alyssa: As I read the comments I'm being reminded of other awesome scenes! YES I absolutely loved Alice in this movie. She totally jumped out at me. Just seeing her in the ballet studio trying to resist Bella's blood was awesome.
  • twinks.
    Personally. I didn't really like the movie. When i walked out of the theatre i was like.. yeah it's okay. Simply because it had it's MOMENTS.

    Charlie definitly made the movie for me though. He was the best actor in the movie by far, and never over-did his part.

    Edward and Bella on the other hand.. were ok. I'm sure there could have been better actors out there, but i guess there could have been worse too.

    But can i just say. EDWARD'S FACIAL EXPRESSIONS WERE HILARIOUS. i dont think they were supposed to be, but i couldn't NOT laugh.

    I also found the dialogue to be very awkward sounding. Like, Edward constantly said UM. which shouldn't bother me.. BUT IT DID. Edward was always supposed to be perfectly composed, and they just sorta threw that out the window but adding in all the um's he says.

    I'll still see the movie again, but im not sure if it was worth losing sleep over to see the midnight showing. If i knew thats how it was going to turn out, i could have waited.
  • Tia
    I also liked when Alice ripped James' head off.

    I also liked how she kicked her leg up when she did the pitching in the baseball scene. It was very smooth and dancer like...just like I imagined her to be.
  • Vanesa
    well i absolutely loved it!!! it was so much more then what i was expect it, like the ballet studio, how many times did we see that scene?? and in the movie, it was like a complete new scene... it gave me the chills.. it was so good...!!! i'll see it several times!!
  • sonia
    Ok, don't get mad at me people, but I did not really like it. I sort of understand now that they did not have a big budget, because I could tell they did not have a big budget. I tried to have lower expectations, but it did not help me. There were a lot of moments that I did enjoy I admit. I did bust up a lot. Jaspers's pain reminded me more of someone holding in a fart than tempting blood. I thought Rob put forth a great effort, and I guess it helps that he lived up to the image of the most beautiful vamp. However, I was disappointed with Bella. I mean she diden't even shed a real tear in the Hospital scene or at any other time. I felt she was a little emotionless, but she got the make out scene right (that was hot).

    I felt this movie was more of a comedy, because I busted up so much. Anyway, I'm going to see it again, because I really do want to like this move. I'm just sad that I'm spending so much time trying to like this movie.

    I just can't figure it out if it was the over the top acting, or the bad direction.

    Again, sorry if I offend anyone, but I'm just being honet with how I feel. I will admit that reading everyone's positive comments is helping me see a little light, so I hope it will help when I take my mom to see it in a couple of days.

    Peace out
  • sally
    wow i just saw it, and even with high expectations, i really really liked it. it was way funnier than i thought it would be, and i also LOVED the part when edward freaks out about bella's smell in biology. it was hilarious. its so intense and jam packed, i feel like i need to go see it again. which im definately going to do soon!
  • I felt like Edward was overacted, and so many of the scenes were overwrought with camera and sound effects (e.g., Bella's scent in biology, the sparkly skin moment in the meadow...did his skin really need to have a sound effect of its own?)

    Still, my husband, who has read none of the books, said he actually enjoyed it and is intrigued to read the books now...so that's good. :)
  • Kaleb-

    Congratz on making it to the premiere! I am also very glad to hear you enjoyed the movie. I flipping LOVED it. The first ten minutes I am thinking 'please God, make this NOT suck' lol and it totally didn't. I also agree with the comedy part of the film, the minor characters did very well bringing the story together and capturing the audience. As for Bella, she was spectacular. There is something about her voice that makes you feel apart of the character and more in sync with the storyline. Robert very much impressed me as Edward. I almost cried twice (piano and closing scene) but that could be the smitten love struck part of my brain talking. Anyways, I squealed seeing Stephanie Meyer in the cafe. So awesome. Thank you for posting your review!
  • Wendy
    My biggest FAIL for the movie is that Bella and Edward did not exchange "I love yous" with each other. Not even once. I didn't like the tree climbing or Edward's expressions in Biology. Looked like he was going to hurl or something. My showing was LOLZ at him. I didn't like Edward's speaking voice at all.


    I really enjoyed the Ballet studio fight (go Alice!) part and the baseball. I also agree w/most of what sonia said.

    I really want to like it more when I see it again.
  • Marissa
    RAWR

    I really liked it!

    SPARKLING WAS PERFECT
    BASEBALL=AMAZING
    fight scene?? **no words**

    I'm defs seeing it again, you hit the nail RIGHT in the head Kaleb! Thank you for an honest review!!
  • [I did not intentionally write spoilers, but don't read anyway until you see the movie.]

    My mother and I went and saw a noon showing on Friday and we were very surprised by the amount of kids ditching school to come see the movie.

    We didn't blame them.

    Also, four buses from the local high school bused in around 100 plus studets to a private early showing of the movie. I wonder if they read it for class. I fervently hope so. There were, however, MANY adult couples in the theater, which was nice to see.

    Kaleb, all I have to say is that I agree with you. Mike + window = tears of mirth. Overall, the movie exceed any expectations I had had. My mother and I agree that this is the first ever movie that we would willingly pay to see twice in the theater. Never has even Harry Potter done that for us.

    Catherine Hardwick is amazing. The characters are so real. I clapped when Edward saved Bella and growled at those guys, oh and when he sparkled. It was perfect.

    Although, Kaleb, you did leave out one crucial funny part.

    Billy and Charlie - background with Bella and Jacob talking about them, right in the beginning. Or, when Edward hops off of her truck. OR the look he gives his family in the kitchen. OR when Jessica is describing the Cullens to Bella and what she had to say about poor Jasper. OH, and the dress thing at the end. All I am saying is Thumbs are WAY up! That dress was too cute. Ah, good times ... good times.

    I ended up going xmas shopping last night at Kohl's and stopped to talk to three workers who were talking about the movie. I walked up to them and I was like "Are you talking about Twilight?" Never before have I had such a funny discussion with three women, one who was in her fifties and the other two in their late twenties, that showed such a varied opinion. Only one had seen the movie and we did both agree that we would have LOVED if Catherine had extended the whole hotel scene with Bella with Jasper and Alice, or even the letter thing near the end. But we centered more on the books and the two of us who HAD seen the movie assured the other two that the next movie is left wide open and would not be a bad idea.

    But, like I said, it was amazing. I think I am going to beg my mother to go with me again on Monday. XD
  • There are A LOT of parts of this movie that I LOVED. I definitely did not expect there to be any funny parts in it but Mike and the window was hilarious. The gun thing with Charlie reminded me of my dad who is also a cop, doing something similar with my sister's boyfriend (now husband) years back. His involved slowly taking the gun out of the holster while staring him down. I LOVED the alley scene. The car stunts were amazing. I just wish they would have shown more of the actual talking they do when they get to know each other. The movie is a bit disjointed in the beginning to me, but it really ties together near the middle. I loveeedddd when they were making dinner for Bella. Rosalie cracked me up when she broke the bowl. I wish they would have shown the letter to Edward and everything and made her escape from the airport a little harder than just walking out of the door, but there's only so much you can do. I loved Alice. It just seemed so much like her! I loved Jasper too. A couple of things they had Emmett say made me laugh. Something struck me as funny when I don't think it was intended to be... It's the scene where Edward first catches Bella's scent. They make it seem like he smells her after two weeks of hard exercise and no showering. Haha. Overall, the movie was great :D
  • Amaranthine
    I have very mixed feelings about the movie. I'm trying really, really hard to like it...but even with low expectations, I was pretty disappointed. I'm not sure what it was exactly. I mean, all the main scenes were there, and all the actors looked great for the part. I think it might have been some of the script and some of the acting...some of the camera angles, a bit of the directing... it just didn't click for me. I mean, I spent over half of the movie laughing. Someone on the local radiostation put it best; it followed the book pretty well, but there were just some of those things that were fantastic scenes in the book, but when put on the screen they looked ridiculous. Carlisle biting Edward for instance...I couldn't contain my laughter. That whole scene seemed off to me. Robert did a great job of portaying the emotions of Edward that I imagined since Midnight Sun. It really looked like he had used it as a source. The "uhms" did get me a little, but I can seriously live with that. I don't want to say anything bad about Kristen, but her acting didn't get me. I just didn't FEEL Bella, and I didn't understand the love between her and Edward. Too rushed. Her constant blinking, head shaking, and stuttering was a bit unnerving as well. But she was lovely and her leaving Charlie was a great performance.
    I think my favorite scenes were the baseball scene (I have no complaints--how could I? I mean...Muse! And the Cullens! Perfection), the ballet studio, and...oh my mind just went blank. I'm running on four hours of sleep. Ah yes, Port Angelas and anything with the Cullens was fantastic. I know it wasn't at all how it was in the book, but Edward's reaction in Biology cracked me up. I actually liked it. :)
    I think one of my biggest complaints is that JUST when I was getting into a scene, looking forward to the exchanges between the characters that I remembered from the book...the scene would end. Bummer. Too short.
  • Mneh.
    Alright, I've gone on and on about this movie so much I really just don't feel like it any more. I still want to share my basic opinion, though.

    I LOVED a lot of parts. I also disliked a lot of parts. My main thing, however, was how very depressed Edward Cullen was. I mean, I know from reading Midnight Sun that the kid was not a happy camper. But, I also know Edward tried his darned hardest to "keep it light" with Bella. He was such a Debbie Downer, if you didn't read the books I really don't think you would have understood their relationship at all.

    So, I guess that was what I missed. Their relationship. The happiness of their relationship, specifically. I really just didn't get WHY Bella loved him.

    My favorite line:

    Rosalie - "Does she even like Italian?"

    Emmett - "Her names Bella." All "duh" like. Giggles.
  • Yoko
    I loved it! And hear hear to this post...my thoughts exactly!
  • Mneh.
    Oooh Oooh! I meant that for Bella, too.

    Bella in the books was hilarious, sarcastic, and Stephenie did an awesome job putting physical comedy into the books.
  • Elodie
    Congrats on the 2million hits! I loved the Mike window scene too! and the scene where Eric says 'bella, look, a worm!' humans are stupid sometimes. the gun part was an excellent touch as well. i have to say that jasper was hilarious. you could really tell it was hard on him, without a doubt. his expression was pricless when he said 'nice to meet you'!!!! i wish there was more of him though, he tends to be overlooked. and his hair looked crispy.

    One of my only complaints character-wise is that Edward invited Bella to see him sparkle, when before he tried to avoid it all together. It doesn't seem like him to disclose his sparkliness.

    I did love, however, the kitchen scene, and how Alice randomly appeared on a branch. I think Alice looked a little bit too tall, but she nailed the voice. Very awkward scene. Very funny.

    I also loved how they used flashbacks from when Esme and Edward were turned, and how Bella invisions herself like the girls in the original Dracula films. Excellent touch.

    All in all, excellent. Funny, and the originality of an independant film.
  • m.a.
    OK, I have seen this movie twice now, and I cannot remember for the life of me what Mike/window scene there was?? It's going to drive me crazy!!

    Kaleb, you rock. I agree with everything you said. I must say that I really liked the movie at the midnight release, but the crowd was much better tonight and without people laughing constantly at every scene, I found that I enjoyed everything much more!

    This is the kind of movie that might seem a little silly in the theater surrounded by over-excited people, but in the privacy of your room would be just as touching and meaningful as the books we know and love!
  • Amaranthine
    I agree with Mneh--Edward and Bella's relationship is what I missed most of all, because it didn't make sense as it was in the movie.
  • Jessie
    Okay, I went to the midnight showing and was probably apprehensive about whether or not the movie would live up to the books. So, after watching it, I thought the movie was well done and yes all the major plot points were there. But, I felt that the movie was very fast paced for some reason. I concluded that I was doing too much comparing between the book and the movie and not really letting the movie "carry" me like the book did.

    So, I saw it again tonight and decided that I wouldn't think about the book at all, and just watch the story for itself.

    Well, that made all the difference for me. I really loved it the second time through!! Everything was there that I had hoped for and the pace of the movie seemed to slow down.

    Overall, I think all of the actors did an amazing job - can't complain. Kristen was Bella and Rob was Edward(never doubted this one). The casting was perfect in my opinion. The story flowed and the relationship between Edward and Bella became much more apparent. Catherine Hartwick did a great job and the music was perfect. Rob's songs really worked!

    There were more couples at the movie tonight and they weren't teens. I got the feeling that everyone was really enjoying the movie.

    I agree, I wished they had said "I love you" to each other at least once - maybe they can put that in at the beginning of new moon. I think Edward and Bella dancing/kissing at the prom was much more romantic than the bedroom scene and would have been the perfect place for the "I love you's". I could really feel the love that they had for each other while they were dancing and I think that is why the other two couples left the gazebo - they could feel it as well and probably felt like they were intruding.

    The lead in for New Moon worked for me as well - which I do think they will make and with a larger budget.

    So, if you were not quite sure of your opinion of the movie or thought it didn't live up to your expectations, I would encourage you to go see it a second time and forget about any preconceived expectations and just experience the movie and let it "carry" you into the Twilight universe.
  • Susan
    I slept only 2 1/2 hours. Love the movie. Can't understand why others can't. Kristen is great but a little 'stiff'; Rob can act really well. He's a great actor. My favorites were the meadow scene where Edward sparkles - just perfect, seems like what the book says, sparkling diamonds; the kissing scene was hot; and the alley scene - you could really feel Edward's anger; well, the baseball, whoa, Alice can bat! Spectacular! I feel it would have been better as an added scene if Bella was dreaming and saying Edward's name - that would be sweet, instead of just mentioning it. Will see the movie with my kids again tomorrow. Rate: 4 1/2 stars.
  • rachel
    well unlike a lot here i hated the movie, it was funny in a omg this is so bad funny way, not like omg thats funny cus it should be. more like laughing at the movie not with the movie.

    i really think it was a badly written screen play, and well... i'm going to be flamed but i hated the dir. going in to this movie i hate her other movies i would pay her money to use a steady cam and pull out of her shots a little. i know she thinks it's art ,i think it's painful to watch.
  • rachel
    oh and like someone else was saying why dose shiny skin have a nosie?

    things like that bug me to no end in movies lol.
  • Brittney H.
    I'm definitely going to have to agree with everything you said, except for my expectations. I expected greatness, and I got it.

    From the opening scene, I was already blown away. Bella with the spade and the cactus cracked me up. At first, it looked like a burial. Which made me ponder if they wanted it to look like a burial, of her life in Phoenix, her life as a normal teenage human girl.

    Charlie was awkwardly hilarious throughout the entire movie, except, of course, for the part where she leaves him to go with Alice and Jasper. That was absolutely heartbreaking.

    I noticed nothing was mentioned about Jasper being an empath, and for a moment it bothered me, but how could they portray it on screen in a way that everyone in the audience could understand?

    Another thing, the lack of the airport scene made me think the anticipation for the final battle was going to be lessened. Then, as I watched the fight scene, I realized there was no need for anticipation, because anything more anxiety-inducing would have given me heart failure.

    I loved the montage of clips from the moment she's bitten to the moment she wakes up in the hospital. Beautifully done. Especially with the deer. I'm really glad they added that in there, as sort of a demonstration to how fragile and helpless she actually is, physically.

    The entire vampire Google search was intense, especially when she pictures herself on the couch with Edward descending to her throat. It was very old school vampire in the best of ways.

    The humans were hilarious, and what was up with the bead curtain in Tyler's van? It doesn't say too many things about the guy's recreational activities. I definitely felt a 60's "carefree" vibe.

    The Eric/Mike battle was funny in the fact that they never stood a chance, not once Edward walked through the doors of the cafeteria.

    Speaking of which, the Cullen's entrace was downright dream-like. It was smooth and graceful, and made ME want to know who they were, even though I already do.

    The baseball scene was phenomenal. Very intense and cocky, in a way. Jasper twirling the bat, Alice with her awesome pitching stance, and everyone so sure of themselves as they raced either toward the ball or toward the home plate. I found it very sexy, in a way.

    There are so many more things I could say about this movie, but I'll just finish with sying that I thought everyone did a phenomenal job, both on and off screen. I applaud each of them , and really hope the other fans of the book enjoy it just as much.
  • Rose
    So was it just in my theater or what???
    You know the part on the trailer when Emmet tells Edward, "she's not one of us." Where in the world was that???
    did it get cut?? WHY??????
    I was extremely sad, and everyone with me was to.
    The movie felt a little too rushed but I thought it was still great. Since I live in Arizona, everyone started screaming when Bella said Phoenix in the begining :)
    But the part I was sad that wasn't there is really random... It's when Bella "hunts" for her breakfast (cereal) and tells Edward that it is no grizzly bear :(
    And i have to mention the Edward and Jacob stare at the end was phenomenal!!!
  • Red
    does anyone else feel the horrific loss at the "Meadow Scene"? Because that's what made the book and their love in my mind and Edward's vulnerability in revealing his sprakly-self was taken away.....honestly that was the point where I almost left the theatre.

    I did stay to finish it and came to the conclusion that while she did a good job, i didn't see Bella in Kristen's eyes, but Rob was great even with too much lipstick :)

    don't love it, don't hate it and i'll take the book over it hands down. best part....SM cameo. I LOVE YOU STEPH!!!
  • I thought it was just okay. It was a wonderful representation of the book, as well as far more real than most teen movies (note: the lockers were not brand-new), but there were some visual things I hated.

    Like the prom scene. Forks is a 2B school. And for all of you who DO NOT know this...that means it's really, REALLY small. Sooooooo said school would have never been able to pay for the beautiful prom that they had.

    Also. Edward's sparkling. Ick. I thought it looked more like he was sweating. A lot. I imagined less of a sparkle and more of a glow, like his skin had florescence underneath.

    Favorite scene: Edward...ballet!!!!

    Funniest scenes:
    1) Emmett: Is she even Italian?
    2) Jessica: "Who are they?"
    3) Charlie: gun
  • Kim
    Overall, I liked the movie! I was really surprised at how much I actually laughed too. Everything came together really well, and I think any fan of the book should enjoy it.

    Some things I wish were different: I would have liked to see more of Alice; looking back, I can see that she's not a huge character in the book, but she's still my favorite. Also, I would have liked to see Edward and Bella spend more time in the meadow, and I think all of the guys inviting Bella to the dance would have been funny to see. On the other hand, I loved the addition of the Cullens cooking for Bella, and Bella and Edward at the top of the huge tree.

    I will definitely be watching this movie again, once I finish my programming project and actually can spare the time.
  • Meg "RFF"
    I completely LOVED the movie...I can't say it enough...I LOVED LOVED LOVED IT! I am SO SO proud of all the cast! They were all so wonderful! I have seen it twice already and will be seeing it on Sunday and probably Monday (maybe even tomorrow) It was wonderfully made and definately fulfilled my expectations and wishes.

    Favorite scenes:

    Vampire Baseball! The song fit perfectly with this scene! Let me just say when they held up the baseball and I saw that it was a wilson one..well, I have never been more proud to be a Wilson in my entire life! :D

    The Ending...I won't say what it is, but when that person walks out of Prom was awesome!

    And of course when Bella goes to the Cullen's house...all I have to say is Emmett is hilarious and Rosalie is perfect!


    Favorite funny parts:

    Charlie with the gun...Bahaha made me die laughing

    Charlie with Tyler..again Bahahaha

    Mike in the Window...wow funny stuff!

    and there is SO SO much more I could say, but I don't want to talk forever lol...it is WONDERFUL! :D
  • Natali
    I loved that the Cullens were making her food when she first came. I hated all the giggling at certain intense scenes (like the kissing or hospital). It is hard to get into it when there is a bunch of giggling teens all throughout the movie. I'll enjoy it on DVD more when I can watch it alone.
  • Ana
    Well first off i loved it!!! The voice over at the begining was just amazing. when bella entered the biology room oh god that was hilarious! The mike window scene hahaha oh so funny! Stephenie meyer in it! Holly crap!! We all screamed lol it did feel a bit rushed like those 2 hours was only 1 :( it felt like i dreamt it all cuz i went to the midnight one and had to go to school lol (my parents and i made a compramise that i could watch it as long as i went to school and boy was i tired) the prom, taylor lautners performance even tho he wasnt in it much, ballet studio scene, the kiss ahh im soo jealous kristen got to kiss those lips.. everything was better than i expected it to be! Oh and at the prom with the edward and jacob glare... amazing! Like i said before i loved it and will be watching it eveytime i go to the movies until they put it on dvd :)
  • Natali
    Yeah, Rachel(See above comment) that was the type of people I got in the Theater. It is hard when they are laughing in a way that is making fun of it(not the actual funny parts but the good parts in the book.)
  • peeves
    I give it 3 to 4 *’s and when Edward sparkles and says this is a skin of a killer i couldn’t take him seriously and i was gasping for air and and was laughing so loud!
  • Laura
    haha, i can't believe there aren't more negative comments here..first i agree with rachel that it was so funny in an 'oh my god this is awful' kind of way. I was cracking up through most of the movie it was just so ridiculously bad. Honestly, i don't understand how anyone liked it. I really thought it was one of THE worst movies i've ever seen in my life. The acting was horrible, the plot didn't flow, the meadow scene was AWFUL!!! ughh..the whole relationship between bella and edward wasn't developed well at all. I really don't have anything positive to say about it at all. I went in with very low expectations and even those were too high. i'm so disappointed.
  • Lisa G
    My 15 year old daughter and I went to see the midnight showing of the movie, along with a twi-hard friend of mine. We all absolutely loved it! Afterward I went online to see what others had to say, and I was so surprised to hear how many people were disappointed. I really didn't understand why. For me, the movie was everything I had hoped it would be and more. I especially loved the humor, which I hadn't expected to play a part in the movie. After thinking on it a while and reading so many varied reviews, I have to agree with Jessie (post #34). I think that people who were expecting to see every detail of the book played out exactly the way the book is written were the people who were disappointed. Those who went in to the movie prepared to view it as a separate entity were those who had more positive things to say. Like everyone else, I was sad to see how rushed the relationship was in the first half, but I knew it had to be that way. Despite how quickly that part moved, I still think it was thorough. Everything was there; it was just condensed. I was so impressed with the entire cast and can't wait to see more of the supporting characters in the next movies. I have to say, though, I was most impressed with Kristen and Rob. I think their roles were incredibly challenging, especially in the context of the script's "condensed book format." There are so many things that they were able to portray with mere facial expressions! I read one comment that expressed disappointment in Kristen for not shedding any tears, but I think Kristen was right on, especially in the hospital scene. I don't think tears would have adequately expressed the utter shock and horror Bella felt when Edward told her they should go their separate ways. Kristen was superb! Rob did an incredible job, too. I loved his portrayal of Edward because he showed us the conflict and seemingly imminent loss of control that Edward felt inside. If Rob had played Edward as cool and unruffled as he is in the book, viewers who don't already understand Edward wouldn't understand this critical element of the relationship. Bella almost instantly demolished the dam Edward had built up over a hundred years of restraining his feelings and urges. Suddenly he has a flood of emotions and desires to try to deal with. Rob revealed Edward's duality. He has a wise, seasoned side from having been in existence for so many years. But he also retains characteristics of a teenage boy. He is a bit rebellious and imetuous and is discovering the rollercoaster of emotions that come with first love. I was fascinated by Rob's ability to show this complexity of Edward's character. He made Edward seem so much more real to me! I've never read a book or seen a movie more than once in my life before Twilight. I've read all four books three times so far, and I intend to see the movie in the theatre at least one more time. I also intend to buy the dvd when it comes out. It will be the only dvd I have ever purchased. I also bought the soundtrack - the only soundtrack I own. Obsessed? Absolutely! And loving every minute of it!
  • Kaleb, you are an excellent writer. You could make anyone like this movie, seriously.

    I thoroughly enjoyed it. Considering most critics are middle-aged men. I guess I can't blame them for hating this movie. But, I still think they're being downright harsh instead of merely critical. Some films deserve it, but even the critic in me can see that this movie is better than what they're saying.

    So basically...
    The critic in me gives it a C+ (average)
    And the fangirl in me gives it an A+

    : )
  • I saw it last night and was the only one out of my group that really enjoyed it. Others thought it was too undeveloped and cheesy. I guess I can see their point but I really enjoyed it more than I thought I would.

    I agree with others who have mentioned it: Bella and Edward not saying "I love you" even once is a major disappointment. I think it might have made a big difference in understanding how deeply in love with a vampire Bella was. Yes, that's the tag line or whatever the actors keep saying in interviews- but half the time she look scared or puzzled. Not in love.

    As far as the actors being true to their book characters, I couldn't have asked for a better cast! Angela was way less shy than the book portrays her but I liked it. Kristen did blink a lot, it was overwhelming. And Jasper- I was glad when he could 'be himself' more at the baseball game. I didn't like the look of constant torture.

    The sparkling effect was ok. The first glance at it, I couldn't even tell and I was throughly disappointed. Maybe it was my angle to the screen but I saw very little sparkle. The more 'meadow' scene helped but it still wasn't that great. I get that it was a hard effect to pull off without overdoing it so I am going to try to like it more the next 2 times I see the movie this week :)

    I also did not enjoy the super close ups of Renee. What was that about?!

    Everything else has pretty much been said so I will just sum up my favorites.

    1. The ending- I love how Edward brings up the 'wolves', the stare he and Jake exchange and the person watching from above, and Bella's 'talk over'.

    2. Emmett. Enough said there. Kellen did a great job (though I missed him in the jeep saying 'she's not one of us Edward'. I hope to see it in the deleted scenes on the dvd) Kitchen, baseball, protector...he was great.

    3. Charlie. Billy brought so much more depth to Charlie that was hard to get from Bella's perspective alone. How carefree he is, how much in love with Bella he is, and I love, love, love the part with Tyler and again when Edward picks her up for Prom "I've heard that before" lol

    I also didn't think I'd laugh a lot- thought I'd be more teary eyed (only once- the goodbye to Charlie) but the more minor characters (Mike, Jess, Eric) provided a ton of humor.

    Great review Kaleb and glad to have the site back!
  • Laura
    I went in with very, very low expectations, and it's a good thing I did, because it barely lived up to those standards. The best thing about the movie was that it really did follow the book VERY well. They hardly changed anything and barely strayed. That was great. I did like the fact that it was funny. There were also a few scenes that were done very well.

    However, the instrumental music was AWFUL. It completely ruined the movie for me. It sounded cheap, cheesy and just plain horrid. The scene where Bella first goes into Biology...I was laughing so hard because of how terribly cheesy that was. Edward's sparkly skin...really? I could have made it look better than that. Kristen did not click as Bella for me. What's with all the eye blinking? Rob did good. He wasn't the best Edward, but he was definitely good. I also didn't feel much chemistry between the two, and their relationship was very rushed. One minute they were barely talking, and the next they were saying they had fallen in love.

    As for the rest of the cast...well, Charlie was amazing. He wasn't the Charlie in the book, but I really loved his character. He definitely made the movie funny. Mike was awesome as well (and very cute)! Carlisle was not attractive AT ALL. That was disappointing. Emmett was PERFECT. I loved him. I thought Rosalie wasn't pretty enough from clips and pictures, but after seeing her in the movie, she was great. Alice and Jasper were both...eh, not the greatest.

    I get that they had a low budget, but seriously? They could have done so much better with this movie. The music, camera angles... ugh, it just wasn't good. Hopefully, New Moon will be much better since they will have a large budget!

    Of course, I've already seen this twice and plan on seeing it a least twice more in theaters. After all, it IS Twilight. =)
  • Sabrina
    I've seen it twice already and planning on a t least one more showing. I thought it was very well done considering it's low budget, it was darn near masterful!
    I still don't care for the soundtrack, but the films score was beautiful and exciting and I am counting down the days until I can download it.
    Charlie and the gun scene was right up there as one of the most memorable moments and when Edward arrived at the ally, my whole theater actually applauded! I have never enjoyed watching a movie in theater so much as this one because of all the personal interaction, you could hear the besotted giggles when the vamps first grace the screen, their gasps during the ballet scene, and the stunned silence as Bella hurts her father so very badly.
    I really enjoyed your review, and agree with it whole heartedly.
  • I had a really hard time keeping my expectations in check which is why I think I was so disappointed. The review I wrote on my blog is exactly opposite of yours. I want to like the movie SOOOO bad, it just missed the mark for me on several things. With that said though, I plan to see it again next week and I'm hoping that now I know how the movie works itself out I will enjoy it more.
  • Anna
    So, first of all, I have to say I have really mixed feelings about the movie.

    I went in the movie theatre with super low expectations. Mainly because I thought the trailer was awful, but also because I knew it would be hard to translate the books to the screen in a good way. But boy was I relieved going out of there. I’m so glad that it didn’t suck as much as I thought it would. but still, it was far from perfect.

    My main issue was the acting. Mainly on Kristen and Roberts part, I thought it was mediocre - at best. But I was kind of prepared for that since the trailer. The most painful parts was when they where talking about the serious stuff, like the meadom scene (“Say it! Say it out loud!” – “vampire”..) and the cafeteria scene when Edward tells Bella to stay away from him (“Maybe i’m not the hero...”) I could also tell that the director knew these where hard scenes because all of the serious dialogue scenes was really short and kind of abrupt.

    But apart from those scenes I found myself really enjoying the movie and, surprisingly, I didn’t mind all the screaming (and at times almost fainting) girls in the theatre. Maybe it’s because I’m not fifteen anymore (i’m 21) and, rather than feeling ashamed or annoyed, I felt something like nostalgia and a little envy :P Also I liked the music more than I thought I would, and the cinematography that was kind of unconventional for a teen movie was really well made.

    I really think Hardwicke did a great job translating the book. When I first heard they were making a movie I didn’t know what to think because on the one hand, Twilight is almost perfect for the screen, the way it’s dialogue-based makes it easy to adapt. (And that’s also Meyers strenght – making the characters come to life with a fantastic and really vivid dialogue. Which I though got a bit lost in the movie.) But on the other hand I knew it would be difficult because of the pace in the book. It’s really kind of slow (or rather – it’s alot of talk and less action), which works fine in the books bot not in a movie. And also - that it is only one plot, no parallel story whatsoever.

    But as I said, I think she worked aroud that really well and in the end, it became a film well worth watching. But, I still have mixed feelings about it because I couldn’t get away from the feeling that there where ALOT of obstacles to work around. For examples the fact that there was alot of humor and that almost every character besides Edward and Bella was caricatures of themselfes. Don’t take this the wrong way, I really loved some of the funny scenes (like the Cullens making dinner). Maybe it’s all these things together - the caricatures, the lack of feeling in the serious scenes, the rushed tempo in the beginning of the movie – that didn’t made me believe in the story. The lovestory between Bella and Edward was going way too fast. I felt like the humor (though I really enjoyed all of it) and all the surounding things was a way of distracting the audience from the fact that it wasn’t a very well told story, or rather rushed, AND the fact that the main actors where kind of lame.

    This turned out to be a really long post, sorry for that (and sorry for my bad english), but in the end i just have to say: Twilight was a good movie, but not a great one. But with such a small budget, I’m really surprised it came out the way it did.
  • Anna
    I just wanted to add that this was my first ever comment on TwilightGuy although I've been reading it since June.

    Go Kaleb!
  • Devan
    When I first saw the movie, I thought it was a bit stiff, and there was a choppiness to it, going from one scene to another without the flowiness it should. I have to see it again to really give my opinion, but I think it was pretty good, considering the low budget. I liked the ending with Victoria, leaving it open for New Moon.
  • Devan
    There were also a few awkward pauses between Bella and Edward that wouldn't have happened in the book. In the movie, they didn't really show how clumsy Bella was, either. I mean, she shouldn't be able to climb a tree!
    I think the acting was pretty good, except for the fact that Rob was trying to be fierce [baseball scene in particular], but it didn't really work out [LOL!].
    When Edward was telling Bella that he should meet Charlie, I thought that was kind of abrupt.
  • MRK
    I really liked it...and I did enjoy the humor.
    I loved the whole restaurant.."Money, sex...cat" thing...I about died!
    And I LOVED Charlie's scene at the hospital when he is yelling at Tyler...even though I was bummed Edward wasn't in there.
    It was a little fast, I'll admit...but I'm REALLY hoping that the next movie will have a much larger budget.
    I also agree that the closeup shots were a little frustrating...I kept wanting to take a step back.
    Oh! I also LOVE Billy Black in the movie...I thought he was VERY funny!
    And Tyler nailed Jacob PERFECTLY...I was very worried because he is so bubbly in interviews...which Jacob is...but not overly so.
    I thought Kristen was dead on...I was nervous about her as well, but I didnt find her monotone at all...I honestly think the trailers just didnt do a good job...anyway she beacme my Bella!
  • Hope
    I didn't hate the movie but I didn't love it. It was enjoyable

    Parts I liked.

    1.Baseball

    2.ballat studio

    parts I didn't like

    1. Bella going to meet the cullens. (though the hats on the wall was sooo funny)

    2.The meddow sceen, I know a lot of poeple will hate me for this but for some reason I didn't like it.

    3. when bella tell edward that she knows he's a vampire.

    Acters I liked. (I don't know/ can't spell all there names so by charecter)

    Alice (best one in my opinion)

    Emmet

    Mike Newton

    Charlie (not how I picture how he looked but he did a good job)

    Charecters I didn't like

    Esma

    Bella, I never realy felt like she fell in live with Edward.

    EDWARD! I had such high hopes for Rpats but he crushed them all. He was more like the Edward from Midnight sun then Twilight. Yes they are the same guy but in Midnight sun that is how he is INWARDLY but not what he shows Bella. To Bella he is a perfect gentilman and would never be rude like he is at times in the movie. He would never say "Why don't you watch where your going!" unless jokingly.And pull on her arm?!?! Wouldn't he worry he'd hurt her? But now I am renting sorry.

    And Jacob, don't even let me start.



    Charecter I'm not sure about becouse they weren't in it enough to tell!

    All the cullens. Where were they?!?! You never even got to know them in the movie...


    I know I seem to just hate it but I didn't, I enjoyed watching it and am willing to see it again. But if I had seen this movie without reading the books then I don't think I would have even read it.
  • Ok, first of all, I LOVED the baseball scene and the music. I've been waiting for months to see what Muse song(s) were going to be in the soundtrack, and then when they announced it would be THAT song, my favorite Muse song *ever*, I couldn't wait to see where Catherine put it. And it was perfect. I think I squeaked when it started playing. So, so perfect. And I loved the whole soundtrack, really. I sort of wish they would have used Rob's version of the Lullaby (wish I could hear it), because Carter's is sort of boring to me as a piano player, but it meshed well with the rest of the movie, and especially the piano scene.

    ROFL. I LOVE THE GUN SCENE. Oh my gosh. And what about Rosalie's "My monkey man"? Huh, huh? Looooooooove.

    And I loved Mike and Eric and Tyler, and Angela (though she wasn't as shy as I thought she should have been), and even Jessica.

    I have tons of problems with the movie (I won't even list them. It's too many), but even so, I loved it, and I'm definitely seeing it again with my best friend when she gets home for Thanksgiving.

    One thing though: It was too dang SHORT. It should have been like five hours. :-D
  • Dii
    congratulations on the 2 million hits :)

    and thanks for sharing, Kaleb ^_^ this really makes me wish my luck weren't as rotten as it is and I could watch the film.

    glad to read you enjoyed it :)
  • I thought it was really good. Sure, it wasn't like the book, and sure, not all the actors and actresses were perfect, but I understand that no movie is perfectly going to be like the book, and it won't satisfy everyone. ;)

    I LOVED the baseball scene, and I liked it when Bella came into the biology class for the first time. I loved Edward's reaction. And I also liked the scene with Charlie and the gun. And Alice was just awesome.

    What I really didn't like is how they had Bella tell Edward he was a vampire. It was just really awkward. In the book, it wasn't so awkward.
  • Leigh
    I'm still a little iffy on the movie, but i'm sure it will grow on me. i'm still sad about some of the things that were left out. the second half of the movie was by far the best. i absolutly looooved the baseball.
  • avangaline
    I loved the movie!!! It was almost exactly like the book. I was surprised when they aculaly used quotes from the book!! The funniest part was when Jessica was describing the Cullens and said that Jasper was the one that looked like he was in pain all the time!! hahaha. And at the end when Alice riped James head off it was soooo cool!!
  • Kim
    AMAZING! I absolutely loved the movie. I, like every other fan, had my doubts before going into this movie because it's not going to be the same, nothing can ever live up to the book, etc., but I came out of that movie wanting to watch it again. The movie definitely did justice to the book and hit almost every main plot point spot on. The tension in Bella and Edward's relationship was so amazingly portrayed by Kristen and Rob, and their chemistry was phenomenal. Not to mention I almost fell out of my seat during the kiss scene. The baseball scene was a surprising favorite for me, and I really loved Bella's Lullaby and the prom scene as well. There were some really good funny moments too that weren't necessarily cheesy but added another dimension to the story. I do think the pacing of the movie was very fast at some points and I wish they fleshed out some of the characters more, but all things considering, it's only two hours so they have to move a little bit quickly. The casting was perfect, the music was integrated nicely, and all in all, a really great movie by itself and even more importantly, a really amazing adaptation of an even more amazing book.
  • Amanda
    I loved the movie. I went to the midnight show and I had very high hopes. Of course I wish some things were different, but of course I wish the movie could be 8 hours long too, and that can't happen.

    I loved your funny moments, Mike at the window, Charlie with the shotgun, I also loved the boobs at prom, Rene asking "Are you being safe?" and Rosalie talking about her "monkey boy" ha ha ha!

    I was glad the sparkle wasn't Overdone, but I'm not really sure I liked the effect (not that I would know how to do any better) but I thought it was at least subtle enough not to be ridiculous.

    I think my favorite scene overall was the baseball. The whole thing was just fun, the Muse song in the background was perfect, and I thought the effects there were great.

    Edward had some moments when he could have pulled back on the crazy eyes. When he first smells her in biology it looks like he's going to throw up. I couldn't help but laugh, and so did every one else in the theater. But I don't hold moments like that against Robert Pattinson, I think he did a great job and funny moments like that were kinda cute.

    Also, his music in the the film was AMAZING! I loved both of his songs and thought they were placed perfectly.

    I wish the Cullens could have a larger role, but hopefully this sets them up to be a bigger part of the next movies, especially the Eclipse and Breaking Dawn.

    There were a few moments I really think should have been included in the film, and I think they would have made the film better:
    - Edward and Bella needed to say I love you. At least once.
    - When Jasper tells Bella that she's worth it when he and Alice are taking her to Phoenix. It just really makes readers fall in love with Jasper and I think they didn't get that so much without it.
    - They never even talked about Jasper's powers! How can you not talk about Jasper's powers?
    - I wish they would have played up more of Edward's mind reading abilities. Like, when Bella asks him what Jessica is thinking before school. Something.

    Overall I really agreed with your review and with most people who posted on here. I can't wait to see it again. We have to make sure it does well so that they have the money to make the sequels!!
  • flexibleearth
    Sorry, couldn't go through all the entries, but did anyone else would have liked the "Blood Typing" scene to be in the movie?

    But I must admit I was overall impressed with the adaptation that I completely didn't realize that that wasn't in the movie at all.

    And OMG, did everyone hear every girl in the theater gasp when Edward stretched his arms out and made Bella move back into a rock wall trapped with his arms on either side of her?

    SIGH...
  • HeyJoyous
    Love it too! I totally agree with you. Baseball was awesome made more so by the song. I also agree that there were songs on the soundtrack that I didn't like/get but since watching the movie I LOVE them. Charlie with the gun was AWESOME. Billy was unexpectedly hilarious. "Just keepin' it real." HA HA HA I also didn't expect to laugh but did a lot. It was intense and funny and romantice. Just all around awesome. Planning to see it again. . . SOON!
  • Loony_Lovegood
    I totally agree with everything you said! I was a little upset at first, but if you consider how much stuff is in the book, it would be impossible to include everything.
  • Jean
    I am sooooo glad I was not the only one who noticed Stephenie was in one of the scenes. I was the only one I'm pretty sure in my theater who noticed( I live in a very, very small town). Once I pointed it out to my sister though she clicked on it, whereas when I told someone else they were like "Who's Stephenie Meyer?" Poor poor person. The movie rocked, I found so many details that weren't like the book but I do plan to see it many many times and own it the day it comes on DVD.
  • Team Twilight
    Kaleb, there are no words to describe how wonderful this experience has been. When I saw the trailers, I thought "okay it will be alright." But when I saw the movie they totally blew me away! I didn't think they would be able to do with a budget like that but I absolutley adored the movie! Two of my favorite funny scenes:

    1) Renee: "Are you being safe?"

    2) Mike: "So...you and Cullen huh? Yeah, I don't like it." (The way he said it made me laugh)

    One of my favorite scenes was the end when Victoria was standing at the window, anger in her eyes. It makes you wonder if they'll make New Moon. "New Moon Mondays" anyone? :)
  • MRK
    *sorry, but I also agree with another post that they could have cut out the field trip scene and used that time to add a relevent scene from the book. I agreed with the post, that Edward was far too much of a gentleman to have yelled at Bella like that...at least without apologizing. I did miss the scene were Jess wants to be filled on the whole P.A scene...btw Jess and Angela did a good job of being fully Dazzled by Edward!
  • Nazneen
    Really, Kaleb. This is the best review I have ever read. But I didn't bother to read the other comments since I have not watch the Movie. Twilight will be out on the 27th here in Malaysia. But I was so excited as I watched the Countdown Widget when there was 5 minutes left. I didn't feel the screaming atmosphere, but I bet it was a million times way better than when I was screaming all alone in front of the computer like a madman.

    I will be looking forward for the scenes you love and I will definitely send another comment here on your review to share MY favorite scene. THANKS AGAIN, KALEB! Welcome back. (from the break down of the website)
  • katie
    I absolutley LOVED the movie! It was very true the book and I really thought that the actors all did such a great job. I was also surprised at how humorous it was too! All I know is that I'm definatley getting this movie the day it comes out on DVD! :)
  • abbface
    mike...window....HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!

    i also LOVED jessica! she was hilarious!


    YAY FOR MIDNIGHT PREMIERES!!!
  • NuttyNetty
    I LOVED THE MOVIE lol
    oddly enough i found my self falling in love with characters i didn't really give as much thought or expectations for such as Mike Newton CHARLIE (!!) eric yorkie, it was awesome! loved the cast >_<
    and i am soooooo going to see it again and again and again!
    i LOVED the NOMADS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    i think i was the ONLY one in the whole theatre who wore the JAMES shirt with a button that read "YOU BROUGHT A SNACK" lol and it was turning heads and compliments (i know!) i have to say some parts of the movie didn't have to necessarily change but it worked out together in the end :) really LOVED the movie! ;P
  • Ashleigh
    I'm going to have to see this movie a few more times to form an opinion, because right now I'm really torn. In general, I thought the acting was great and everyone did a great job, but the camera work and special effects kind of put a damper on my viewing experience.

    Anyway...great review, Kaleb! But you shouldn't forget the Cullens cooking dinner in your list of funniest scenes. :]
  • Alli
    Rose- I KNOW!!! My friend pointerd that out! It irritated me.

    I have four specific problems with this movie: Edward was a little crazed-looking in some parts, and he's supposed to be smooth; Bella didn't fight the prom thing enough; the meadow didn't meet my expectations; and they cut out my favorite line.

    Then I have one little annoyance that has nothing to do with the book. I understand not putting Jacob's hair in a ponytail to avoid a subconscious connection to James, but what the heck was that headband in his first scene?! His hair looked like Bella's!

    Other than those things, I absolutely loved the movie. There were times when I would (in my head) grumble or go "Hey, wait a minute..." but I reminded myself that there are books and there are movies, so none of those moments except the four I mentioned hurt the movie for me.

    Haha. "Mike...window....Charlie...gun." I don't remember the Jasper thing though. A few of my favorite funny scenes were Emmett...knife (you might not have caught that if you weren't paying attention); Edward...prom("I leave you alone for two seconds and..."); and in the jumping throught the trees part, both my best friend and her sister (I was sitting between them so they couldn't hear each other) asked me "Why would you take Bella in a tree?" to which I responded "Edward can catch her."
  • KIM
    OME I loved the movie!!!!! I convinced 3 of my friends who haven't read the books to come with me, one was even a guy. All of them really liked. The best part was seeing their reactions because they had no idea what was coming next, but i did. I will definatly see it again. We also meet Taylor Lautner's (Jacob) cousin, and me and my friends freaked out!!!!!! the only things i was disapointed about were that they left out...
    1. blood typing
    2. bella's heart racing at the hospital
    3. and all the stuff amanda #67 said was left out.

    but overall that was EPIC!!!!!!
    :)
  • Kim
    I didnt read all the comments so i don't know if this was mentioned yet or not. i was in hysterics when bella and edward were in the restaurant and he was telling her he could read minds. when he read all the peoples minds in the room and was like "money.. sex.. money.. sex.. cat"
  • Great review Kaleb! I have to agree, the movie was well worth the wait :)
    Although, it did feel a bit rushed. They cut out some key dialogue scenes...but I understand that it had to be done.
    I loved the Mike/Window scene XD Bahaha, and the entire cast did extremely well.
    I was a bit disappointed with the "Edward flying" also. It just didn't look as I had imagined it would. But, it wasn't awful. And it's like you said, the little problems are so minor you don't really notice them.
    Anyways, I'll be seeing this movie two more times and I definitely cannot wait :)
    Again, great review. You put into words what I couldn't lol
  • Lucy
    I loved it! I just wished it was longer! I wanted it to go on forever and ever! Catherine Hardwick is a goddess! I loved Charlie and the gun, mike at the window. Oh! Stephenie was awsome! I didn't expect for her to be right there! I thought she would be in the back somewhere and I'd have to search for her.
    There was the last scene where Edward and Jake glare at eachother. More than half the kids in the theater started laughing. I guess you can tell who read and didn't read the books.
  • Feven
    afreakingmazing.

    when i was watching the movie i was just constantly absorbing new and amazing things.. the only thing that was a letdown were some of the vampire effects (but i DID like the sparkle) but all the characters were AMAZING.

    robert's & kristen's chemistry is fantastic!!!!

    &im pretty sure people have already mentioned it.. but that jacob edward stare down at the end scene..
    i was like GAME ON!

    i'm gonna go see it again tomorrow :)
  • I can't even begin to describe how much I loved that movie. It doesn't matter that a few things were out of order or that some things were added in....it FELT like Twilight. I don't care what anyone says to the contrary, I think it was as close it perfect as it could possibly be. I started reading the series when it was first released and have read each book at least 7x's each(barring BD, I've only read that one 3x's so far ;-) and I can't wait for the next!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Oh! and one more thing...I LOVED IT! Just incase you couldn't tell.

    And to KIM- Bella's heart did race in the hospital, you could hear the *BEEPING* in the bcakground get faster.
  • Rhiannon
    To be perfectly honest, I had no expectations for this movie...at all. Which helped me like it more, oddly enough. I went early in the day so that I didn't have to deal with the theater full of screaming girls.
    I was impressed though by the amount of actual jokes that were funny. A lot of the movie though...honestly, I was in hysterics. The Carlisle biting Edward and Edward getting the venom out of Bella's system had me crying from laughter. I wasn't satisfied with Bella and Edward though...it just didn't seem...right. I know how hard it must be to do it right, especially with all the pressure, but it wasn't overly horrible. Really awkward looking and an unemotional Bella, but not too bad. I can get over it.

    But let's end on a good note. The baseball scene with Muse was absolutely perfect. Bella leaving her father was perfect too, she did a great job. It brought on the right emotions and everything. A lot of the supporting actors did a great job. I wasn't entirely impressed with Jacob, Carlisle, and Billy, but all the others did well. I'm definitely going to see it again soon, so maybe a second time through might help my opinion.

    Oh, and good review! Except for that little Harry Potter jibe at the end there, totally unnecessary. Harry Potter needed to create so much more, and it had to be the basis for the next seven movies. In addition, it doesn't really help the whole trying to pull Twilight away from Harry Potter idea, considering they shouldn't be compared at all.
    Anywho, thank you for pointing out the Stephenie Meyer glimpse! I can't believe I missed it! Ah well, second time should be the charm...
  • Sophie
    So, yes, the movie was brilliant, but I did miss the blood typing part. They did need a bit more from Jasper, but other than that they did a fantastic job.

    I didn't expect to laugh much, as well, but my friends and I couldn't breathe during the majority of the time. After a while, I found myself shaking and clutching my stomach—part excitement, part from laughing hysterically. I expected constant hyperventilation, but, wow, that was amazing.

    The music just kind of won. I didn’t get it all when I heard them on iTunes, either, but they fit all of the songs in perfectly. My friend about died, saying “that’s just great” and hitting the theater seat, when I told her exactly who wrote two of the songs.
  • Bethany
    I decided that I was going to see Twilight with an open mind, knowing that the movie can never be just like the book. And I truly loved it. I felt that the movie had exactly the right feel. And Robert Pattison? Well, there's not much to say other than AMAZING! lol. The characters all lived up to my expectations, some exceeding them. And vampire baseball was incredible!!! Sure, I had my moments where I said to myself, "I wish...", but overall, I was not disappointed. And thus I say: Bring on New Moon! :)
  • Christine k
    I saw the movie last night and i loved it! I didn't expect it to follow the book so well and the characters played their parts very good. Coming into the theater i had my doubts on how Bella, Edward, and everyone else were going to be portrayed and how they were going to do some of the more complex scenes but by the first couple of minutes i was hooked, I was completely into every second of the movie. I got lots of laughs. Charlie is so awesome and i LOVE Alice so much.
    Out of all the movies from books this one was by far the BEST. I give it a bazillion thumbs up. I think I'll watch it again real soon :D!
  • Rakey
    I loved the movie, and so did my friends that I went with. I was expecting it to be not too great, but I was pleasantly surprised.

    I really loved Edward's face when Bella fell asleep on him. He looked like he was so awkward and stuff. And the Charlie gun thing had the theatre erupting in laughter. I really didn't expect the movie to be funny, as you did.

    When Edward first said "Hello", it also had the theatre erupting. And Jasper at the Cullen house--- you could tell he wasn't breathing and was stiff and everything. And Rosalie dropping the bowl... and I could go on forever.

    I loved it. It's now officially my favorite movie.

    Although, I was disappointed that they left out the "dazzle" part in Port Angeles.
  • lauren
    I agree with the funny parts, Kaleb. They made me laugh hysterically! But I felt that the movie, although it kept the general feeling of the book, was very rushed. There was no build up, and everything after the meadow scene happened very haphazardly. It didn't really seem to flow. I still really liked it, of course, but that's what I thought.

    I was also kinda disappointed by Charlie. He was too calm throughout the film. It didn't really show the attachment he had to his daughter. And all the "human" kids talked exactly like a forty year old woman trying to be cool. It didn't really make sense.

    Still, it was great to see the characters brought to life. Everyone in the theater squealed when Stephenie Meyer went on screen-- That was awesome!
  • Ally
    I went in yesterday having heard mixed reviews, so I didn't really have any expectations for it. But I absolutely loved it!

    Obviously, there's always gonna be a purist who thinks it's bad even if it was seven hours long, changed nothing from the book, and had all the actors hand picked by the purist. They'd claim something like, "It didn't convey the SPIRIT of the book!" Oh please. Talk like that drives me INSANE.

    Film and books are two entirely different mediums, and making a book into a movie is always walking a fine line. I think they did a great job, even if there were some things from the book that I missed.

    I laughed, I cheered, and I jumped up and down in my seat. I didn't cry though, I never cry for movies. I know... what an abnormal female I am.

    My favorite parts were when Bella hit Jacob with the door, Edward saved Bella in the alley, the adapted meadow scene, Charlie with the gun, and of course the fight scene in the dance studio. I absolutely loved the last part with Victoria.

    My only complaint about the movie was the soundtrack. I really wish they would have had an actual film score instead of a selection of songs. Don't get me wrong, I liked the songs but as a fan of film composers I enjoy movies more when they have their own music.
  • Annie
    Wow, I really loved this movie. The only dissapointment for me was almost being trampled by some overzealous Twi-moms.

    I didn't really like Jasper, but, after seeing him being portrayed in film, I love him. one of my friends and I have decided that he could be Johnny Depp's son.

    My favorite funny part was when Edward was in Bella's room, and she was talking to her mother. "Are you at least being safe?" I cracked up!
  • Stephanie
    really? people liked it? i am a huge fan of the books and i definately went to the midnight release. of course i was not expecting it to live up to any expectations, but it did not even live up to the low standards i had.
    i felt like they cut out a lot of my favorite scenes. the meadow scene was practically non-existant. there was only one kiss!
    i admit the twilight books have a lot of cheesy lines, but they work in context. the movie took the cheesy lines but in different context and i could not help laughing at how dumb it all sounded. anyways, i am disappointed, but i will end my rant here, because i will get far too carried away if i havent already.
  • Amaranthine
    After reading a good portion of these comments, I think I really need to see the movie again. I need to give it another chance, without connecting it in my mind with the book. Perhaps then I can enjoy it...
  • Stephanie
    my main problem with it is that we did not really get to know edward or the cullens. if i had not read the books, i would not understand why everyone is so obsessed with him. we lost a lot of dialogue between bella and edward in the movie. in the movie, edward talks to bella one time, which does not reveal much, and she realizes she is in love with him, and without reading the books, you really dont know why. anyways, i thought since stephenie was so involved in the movie, she would have said something! i think she is to non-confrontational to say anything...
  • betsy
    Congrats on 2 million hits!

    I went to see the movie at the midnight showing, and I left the theater with mixed feelings. Thankfully everyone contained their swooning and overall giddiness for the majority of the movie so we could hear what the actors were saying. Overall though I thought is was pretty good. I wasn't too thrilled with sparkly Edward (Robert)--although I knew they didn't want to make it look comical to those who haven't read the book. When Peter Facinelli walked through those hospital doors after the car accident scene my mouth dropped. If he isn't Carlisle, I don't know who is. And he was soft spoken like I imagined, and, of course, beautiful. And Ashley Greene as Alice also stood out to me. She was the cute pixie vamp Stephenie described in the book.
    I did cry a little once when Edward (Robert)
    was telling Bella (Kristen) to go live with her Mom in Jacksonville so he couldn't hurt her anymore--her reaction was spot on. Because of how the movie flowed, he never really spoke explicitly about him leaving her (at least I didn't catch it) and so she never had that seed of doubt before that moment and she just completely freaked out. I know that sounds silly because I've read all the books and know what happens but for some reason that emotion, that feeling of desperation really resonates with me because of a personal experience. I digress...the screenplay seemed stinted and the meadow scene seemed schizophrenic probably because they weren't moving around so much in the book and I wasn't expecting it. Also it seemed like suddenly Edward just blurts out "so the lion falls in love with the lamb," and they go into that part of the conversation.
    Like so many people I didn't expect the movie to be part comedy. It definitely lightens the overall mood of the movie which was I thought was good.

    I then saw it a second time Friday night with my Mom (the line was crazy-long and when we finally got to the end she turned to me and said, "I hate you." Of course she wasn't serious, she was just surprised at everyone's...tenacity.) The second time around I went in with no expectations and just let the movie speak for itself. I left the theater that time with much better feelings. The screenplay works wonderfully for a book adaptation and in the meadow scene Edward (Robert) was trying to freak Bella out so she'd get scared and leave running and screaming. The "and so the lion..." part seemed in the right place the second time--there's a little bit of a pause I didn't catch the first time.

    I was surprised they showed Carlisle turning Edward and Esme, and it caught me off guard. And although people were laughing when Edward was having a hard time stopping in the ballet studio when he was sucking out the venom in Bella's arm I though Robert did a wonderful job displaying the emotion I'm sure Edward felt when he thought he couldn't stop and was going to kill her himself. Overall I think he did a great job. As did the rest of the cast, really. There were parts, like when the nomads confronted the Cullen's in the baseball scene after they smell Bella--the snarling/growling was comical. I actually laughed out loud and had to cover my mouth. It just sounded like they were breathing hard. And I do understand with such a small budget that it probably would have been different had they had a larger budget so I just let it go.

    Overall, I'd like to say good job to everyone involved in the movie!
  • DJ
    What was really needed:
    -Bella's swooning over looking at him
    -Edward's genteel air and eloquence; PLEASE stop acting like you’re slow in the head
    -Where's the 'I love you' part?!
    -Alice's friendship could be developed more
    -Where's the blood lab scene?!
    -Better special effects & music
    -Bella's cooking for her dad arrangement
    -Younger casting for Rosalie; she looked almost 30 somehow even though the actress is 20
    -Jasper's abilities to be more apparent and looking less than a weirdo
    -Should have cast a different waitress in the restaurant scene

    What was done well:
    -Impressive baseball scene (my favorite)
    -Edward and Bella's first night together
    -Edward's Volvo rescue scene was acceptable
    -Bella's dad was pure awesomeness!
    -Bella's clumsy routine
    -Kristen, you are the gem of the movie! You have a personality! And you’re not whiny!! Also I feel bad for her talent being wasted on some lame scenes
    -Jacob's acting was freakin’ great
    -James was also pretty good, especially in the ballet studio
    -Classmates of Forks High gave amazing performances
    -I guess I'll give credit to the prom scene, kind of....
    -Edward's mind reading was portrayed okayish

    What I could have done without:
    -Crappy meadow scene with glitter sound effects/ Edward’s constant moving
    around in lame positions while confessing his feelings
    -Edward's overacting when he first sees her (funny nonetheless)
    -Cheesy 'believe in yourself' lines from Dr. Carlisle
    -Bella lying about her prom schedule
    -The crazy mindless zombie way Carlisle bit Edward
    -Bella's lame refusal to have Edward leave her
    -Meyer's 'in your face' cameo
    -The Cullen's less than grand/ classic home
    -Victoria's lame vigil over prom
    -Playback during end credits, omg, so bad!!
    -Awkward close ups were unnecessary plus retarded camera angles

    Verdict: C. I love the book but not this mess. A 12-year old with no experience of good movies might appreciate this one. They could have done a much better job considering a few strong scenes. Director & editors SUCKED!!! The word I’m looking for is AMATEURS!! Let’s go, Harry Potter!
  • :: emily ::
    i really enjoyed the movie, your favorite scenes and funny scenes were right on :DD and i really loved the alley one.

    the only thing i must say i was extreamly disappointed with was that they didn't put the "Do I dazzle you?" line in there. i was really upset, i think i speak for others when i say that was one of my favorite lines in the entire book and even series, and i was sad that it didn't make it on there :[[

    but other then that minor detail, i really loved it. Robert did an EXCELLENT job with Edward, the way he looked like he was in pain because he wanted to kill her so badly but couldn't. And Micheal was absoulutly HILARIOUS XDD and even though it was added in there, i liked Victoria at the end. it was unexpected and cool. Although they maybe should have had Laurent there as well since he appears in New Moon. But i liked Victoria at the end

    Out of 10, i would give it a 9.65 :]]
blog comments powered by Disqus

Not responsible for ad content