Comments on: Eclipse: The Epilogue http://www.twilightguy.com/2009/03/23/eclipse-the-epilogue/ A Guy reads Twilight by Stephenie Meyer Thu, 09 Feb 2012 17:38:20 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.0.3 By: Isidora http://www.twilightguy.com/2009/03/23/eclipse-the-epilogue/comment-page-2/#comment-37986 Isidora Thu, 15 Dec 2011 19:17:35 +0000 http://www.twilightguy.com/?p=3139#comment-37986 By the way, I SOOO DISAGREE with the selection of song. To be precise, with first two songs - by Paramore and Katy Perry. They are suposed to represent Bella's opinion, right? It's so wrong! Bella would never, ever say something like that! Don't forget that EDWARD is the meaning of her life ( sounds so strange, but it is true). She agrees to marry EDWARD. She says she can't live without EDWARD. Remember that;) <br><br>But the song by Secondhand Serenade would fit. And I don't really get the last one. Whose point of view  is described there? Edward's, Bella's or Jacob's ? O_o<br><br>Also have to say that those songs remind me how big influence Jacob has in Eclipse. This is completely his book, it even ends with his name. And these things that I've just said remind ME how much I don't like ( I guess that ' hate' is too strong word) that character ( Jacob Black, I mean). Hoping that BD will be more Edward and Bella's story :/<br><br>Once again, sorry for my crappy English :)<br> By the way, I SOOO DISAGREE with the selection of song. To be precise, with first two songs – by Paramore and Katy Perry. They are suposed to represent Bella's opinion, right? It's so wrong! Bella would never, ever say something like that! Don't forget that EDWARD is the meaning of her life ( sounds so strange, but it is true). She agrees to marry EDWARD. She says she can't live without EDWARD. Remember that;)

But the song by Secondhand Serenade would fit. And I don't really get the last one. Whose point of view  is described there? Edward's, Bella's or Jacob's ? O_o

Also have to say that those songs remind me how big influence Jacob has in Eclipse. This is completely his book, it even ends with his name. And these things that I've just said remind ME how much I don't like ( I guess that ' hate' is too strong word) that character ( Jacob Black, I mean). Hoping that BD will be more Edward and Bella's story :/

Once again, sorry for my crappy English :)

]]> By: Isidora http://www.twilightguy.com/2009/03/23/eclipse-the-epilogue/comment-page-2/#comment-37987 Isidora Thu, 15 Dec 2011 17:32:01 +0000 http://www.twilightguy.com/?p=3139#comment-37987 IT'S PROBABLY TOO LATE AND YOU ARE NOT READING THESE COMMENTS ANYMORE, BUT....<br><br>I was really late to catch onto Twilight phenomenon as well. I started reading Twilight in June 2011 and from Sptember to 15th December (2011) I've been reading Eclipse, although I became a Twi-hard in 2008(first film), by watching the films more times that I can count.<br> <br>First time i've heard of your blog was in 2010, after i had saw you in 'Twilight in Forks: Saga of the real town'.  So now, after every chapter I read, i go to this blog to see your and other fans' opinions. In a few days, mum and dad are gonig to buy me ' Short second life of Bree Taner' and then glorious Breaking Dawn :))) I' ve already seen the film ( part 1), so I don't understand why lots of fans hate it... I am really looking forward to reading it :)<br><br>I' am also taking months to read Twilight books and perhaps it is a bit strange. But it is not that I am a slow reader, I just want to fully enjoy the book. I like the way you are reading it so deeply, between lines, just like I do ( that is advantage of slow reading ;) <br><br>Just like Tracey said: ' I suffer right along with Edward, Bella & Jacob and hate how much <br>they all hurt in their own ways. I don't remember ever having cared so <br>much about characters in a book before.' - so true. And that's the beauty of this amazing saga. At this moment, books are so much better than the films to me ( I can't believe I am actually saying this!)  But I found Eclipse the worst book in the series cause Bella is so out of her character and SO ANNOYING. She's ruined this book for me. I am honestly hoping there will be more of Edward ( <3 !!!) in the next book.<br><br> Also, TOTALY AGREE with Wendilynn:  'I never really felt that Bella was truely being disloyal to Edward. Only<br> Jacob thought he ever had a chance. To Bella and Edward there was no <br>question of them being together.' -  she has always loved Edward, but it's painful to watch/read about Edward's pain and suspicion that Bella caused him. Like I said, she is such an annoying jerk in this book!<br><br>P.S. Sorry for my crappy English :(<br><br>Much love from Montenegro<3 IT'S PROBABLY TOO LATE AND YOU ARE NOT READING THESE COMMENTS ANYMORE, BUT….

I was really late to catch onto Twilight phenomenon as well. I started reading Twilight in June 2011 and from Sptember to 15th December (2011) I've been reading Eclipse, although I became a Twi-hard in 2008(first film), by watching the films more times that I can count.
 
First time i've heard of your blog was in 2010, after i had saw you in 'Twilight in Forks: Saga of the real town'.  So now, after every chapter I read, i go to this blog to see your and other fans' opinions. In a few days, mum and dad are gonig to buy me ' Short second life of Bree Taner' and then glorious Breaking Dawn :) )) I' ve already seen the film ( part 1), so I don't understand why lots of fans hate it… I am really looking forward to reading it :)

I' am also taking months to read Twilight books and perhaps it is a bit strange. But it is not that I am a slow reader, I just want to fully enjoy the book. I like the way you are reading it so deeply, between lines, just like I do ( that is advantage of slow reading ;)

Just like Tracey said: ' I suffer right along with Edward, Bella & Jacob and hate how much
they all hurt in their own ways. I don't remember ever having cared so
much about characters in a book before.' – so true. And that's the beauty of this amazing saga. At this moment, books are so much better than the films to me ( I can't believe I am actually saying this!)  But I found Eclipse the worst book in the series cause Bella is so out of her character and SO ANNOYING. She's ruined this book for me. I am honestly hoping there will be more of Edward ( <3 !!!) in the next book.

 Also, TOTALY AGREE with Wendilynn:  'I never really felt that Bella was truely being disloyal to Edward. Only
Jacob thought he ever had a chance. To Bella and Edward there was no
question of them being together.' -  she has always loved Edward, but it's painful to watch/read about Edward's pain and suspicion that Bella caused him. Like I said, she is such an annoying jerk in this book!

P.S. Sorry for my crappy English :(

Much love from Montenegro<3

]]> By: ummhedaya http://www.twilightguy.com/2009/03/23/eclipse-the-epilogue/comment-page-2/#comment-34048 ummhedaya Wed, 28 Apr 2010 05:03:08 +0000 http://www.twilightguy.com/?p=3139#comment-34048 Hey, thanks for your posts... I've really enjoyed reading your humorous view of the book... Eclipse is by far my favorite book of the entire series and I'm thankful to have others to share the experience with. Hey, thanks for your posts… I've really enjoyed reading your humorous view of the book… Eclipse is by far my favorite book of the entire series and I'm thankful to have others to share the experience with.

]]> By: ummhedaya http://www.twilightguy.com/2009/03/23/eclipse-the-epilogue/comment-page-2/#comment-33197 ummhedaya Wed, 28 Apr 2010 01:03:08 +0000 http://www.twilightguy.com/?p=3139#comment-33197 Hey, thanks for your posts... I've really enjoyed reading your humorous view of the book... Eclipse is by far my favorite book of the entire series and I'm thankful to have others to share the experience with. Hey, thanks for your posts… I've really enjoyed reading your humorous view of the book… Eclipse is by far my favorite book of the entire series and I'm thankful to have others to share the experience with.

]]> By: Tracey (Australia) http://www.twilightguy.com/2009/03/23/eclipse-the-epilogue/comment-page-2/#comment-23974 Tracey (Australia) Tue, 31 Mar 2009 03:34:07 +0000 http://www.twilightguy.com/?p=3139#comment-23974 I was so late to catch onto the Twilight phenomenon...but think I'm making up for it by reading the entire series 3 times since 6Feb09 and having seen the movie now so many times I stopped counting. I have loved reading your reviews and all the insightful comments of your readers. Well done for prompting all the discussion. Eclipse is my favourite book in the series, and the only one that made me cry (each time). I suffer right along with Edward, Jacob & Bella and hate how much they all hurt in their own ways. I don't remember ever having cared so much about characters in a book before. Really looking forward to following your thoughts on BD. I was so late to catch onto the Twilight phenomenon…but think I’m making up for it by reading the entire series 3 times since 6Feb09 and having seen the movie now so many times I stopped counting.

I have loved reading your reviews and all the insightful comments of your readers. Well done for prompting all the discussion.

Eclipse is my favourite book in the series, and the only one that made me cry (each time). I suffer right along with Edward, Jacob & Bella and hate how much they all hurt in their own ways. I don’t remember ever having cared so much about characters in a book before.

Really looking forward to following your thoughts on BD.

]]> By: Tash http://www.twilightguy.com/2009/03/23/eclipse-the-epilogue/comment-page-2/#comment-23744 Tash Fri, 27 Mar 2009 14:35:37 +0000 http://www.twilightguy.com/?p=3139#comment-23744 Thanks for your insightful (guy) views on the books its always so interesting and entertaining!! Thanks for your insightful (guy) views on the books its always so interesting and entertaining!!

]]> By: Jasmine http://www.twilightguy.com/2009/03/23/eclipse-the-epilogue/comment-page-2/#comment-23737 Jasmine Fri, 27 Mar 2009 05:16:47 +0000 http://www.twilightguy.com/?p=3139#comment-23737 I've been reading your blog for a while but haven't ever commented. The blog is really funny and insightful. I like your review of Eclipse. It's my favorite book in the series. :) I can't wait to see your thoughts on Breaking Dawn. I have somewhat mixed feelings on Breaking Dawn. I’ve been reading your blog for a while but haven’t ever commented. The blog is really funny and insightful. I like your review of Eclipse. It’s my favorite book in the series. :) I can’t wait to see your thoughts on Breaking Dawn. I have somewhat mixed feelings on Breaking Dawn.

]]> By: Jo http://www.twilightguy.com/2009/03/23/eclipse-the-epilogue/comment-page-2/#comment-23731 Jo Thu, 26 Mar 2009 23:23:46 +0000 http://www.twilightguy.com/?p=3139#comment-23731 Loved Eclipse and all of it's banter. Couldn't have said any of this better, you nailed it. Glad you finished it, hope you enjoy Breaking Dawn. :) Loved Eclipse and all of it’s banter. Couldn’t have said any of this better, you nailed it. Glad you finished it, hope you enjoy Breaking Dawn. :)

]]>