Reading Breaking Dawn: Chapter 1 (Engaged)

March 30th, 2009 at 12:07 am by Kaleb Nation

The song for this chapter is Lifestyles of the Rich & Famous by Good Charlotte

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

I can hardly believe that after almost an entire year of writing for TwilightGuy.com, I am finally reading the last book in the Twilight Saga.

I can still remember the weeks we waited for this novel in 2008. I remember the last two days especially, when the fansites were working overtime to squash the people who were posting spoilers. I remember staying up that evening to watch Stephenie read the first parts of the book at her release party online. And then, finally, the world could read Breaking Dawn.

Obviously, between Eclipse and the fourth book in the series, much has changed for Bella Swan. She has a new car. A new credit card. She even has a new set of rumors floating around town about her (as if she didn’t have enough of those already). It’s no wonder the townspeople can’t stop staring at her. If you saw a teenage girl getting married to a 90-year-old man who showered her with expensive gifts, wouldn’t you start to wonder what was really going on? When you think of how this sounds, perhaps it’s actually a very, very good thing that Edward is a vampire and doesn’t appear anywhere near his real age, or else the town would really be talking :D

I think a lack of sleep caused my vision to be a bit blurry as I started reading, because when I read this line:

…in her minivan, Mrs. Weber had turned her whole torso in my direction. [...] I tried to take some comfort in the fact that she wasn’t really staring at me, just the car.

I instead saw the ending as

I tried to take some comfort in the fact that she wasn’t really staring at me, just the cat.

megacat

Which might have changed the story of this book quite a bit:

To be irrevocable in love with a vampire is both fantasy and nightmare woven into a dangerously hightened reality for Bella Swan. Pulled in one direction by her intense passion for Edward Cullen, and in another by her profound connection to werewolf Jacob Black, she has endured a tumultous year of temptation, loss, and strife to reach the ultimate turning point.

Then, the Megacat appears.

A creeping, monstrous creature of the night, the cat towers above the city of Forks, casting its shadow all across La Push and blocking the sun in what could only be a new form of an eclipse. It desires one thing before the break of dawn: that which terrifies Bella so, that which has held her sleepless for many a night; that which Bella refuses to give to any creature excluding a vampire or alternatively a werewolf.

Her life...bo

[Note to Stephenie: it was my idea first. Hands off.]

Stephenie refers to Bella’s shiny black credit card on page 5 (for future reference, I’m using the hardcover book). Of course, being one who cares absolutely nothing for the frivolous lives of the rich and/or famous, I have never wasted my time looking these up. Since nobody cares anyway (and especially not me) I am probably boring the stuffing out of all my readers by saying that the Centurion Card is crafted from titanium and requires a minimum of $250,000 spent per year. Since no one is curious, I won’t post any photos.

I find it hilarious that Edward got Bella a car that is primarily used by arms dealers, drug lords, and various other criminals:

Bella's New Friends

Bella's New Friends

But in a strange way I can sympathize with Bella and her new driving troubles. Not that I have ever driven a European* car that comes with its own paparazzi, but the ridiculous stopping and starting that one does when getting adjusted to a new vehicle you are not accustomed to driving. I can still remember the first time that I drove my grandmother’s car instead of my mom’s van (which I had done all my driving practice in). Obviously, my grandmother’s brakes were newer, so that when I nervously made a turn at an intersection and lightly tapped the brakes, instead of slowing down I found myself stopped in the middle of the road completely. Then the light changed.

It’s nice to see that Bella’s mother supports her; and that at least Charlie isn’t taking his gun after Edward. It did strike me as odd that no one has even put forth the possibility of Jacob’s disappearance being Edward’s fault. After all: Jacob loves Bella; Edward loves Bella; Jacob disappears; Edward and Bella get married. The obvious conclusion the Forks Police Department should have surmised from this is that Edward and Jacob had an old-style duel-to-the-death, the winner taking Bella’s hand in marriage.

What Really Happened

What Really Happened

Still, it’s wonderful to see Bella in her happy place at last, even though her best friend can’t be there to share it with her. Or will he? I’ve never known Jacob to sulk away for too long, so judging the size of this book I expect there are plenty of surprises for me in the following chapters :D

Question For The Comments: If you were Bella’s parent, would you be happy with her getting married to Edward Cullen that young? Also, same question, but what if she was marrying Mike Newton instead?

——NOTES——

- After all the questions about what a Bound Galley is, I decided to actually show everyone on video:

* is this grammar fail? An European car? A European car?

Bookmark and Share

Posted in Breaking Dawn

Related Posts:

Reading Breaking Dawn: Chapter 2 (Long Night)
Reading Breaking Dawn: Chapter 24 (Surprise)
  • carolina
    Hahaha funny pics
    OMG i just luv the twilight saga
  • orangegirl10
    I read eclipse but not breaking dawn and i cant wait i almost cried at the end of eclipse. My favorite quote from eclipse was "The clouds i can handle. But i cant fight with an eclipse." Jacob says that to bella when she ays that he is her sun!!!!! so romantic
  • DramaQueen
    I'v been wanting to read this book but I can't because I'm on New Moon. I'm half way through chapter 10. I love this series!!!
  • daydreamer13
    if i were bella's parents i were trust her jugment to be the right one and for her to make the right choice.
  • emily boone
    i love the twilight series its awsome ive read every book at least 6 times already
  • It is does'nt really make a difference to the parents if Bella marries Edward or Mike, they don't know that Edward is a vampire and Mike isn't. Her Dad may like it better however because he always thought Mike Newton was "a nice boy" but everyone knows Charlie's dream is for Bella to marry Jacob. If I was Bella, I would personally choose Jacob, he has always been there for her.
  • marissa
    well if bella were my child i would probably be okay with it because i know that her and edward really love each other and i also know that edward will not let anything bad happen to bella. bella is a person who will make the right decision. i would be able to trust her. she is a smart girl and a very good person.
  • Tia_jb10 (Team Pants Explode!)
    i would be fine with them gettin married with a child like bella i can trust that she would make the rite decision and edward is amazing so i cant see why anyone wouldnt approve.oh and i personaly dont like mike n. hes soooo annoying i would not allow bella to be in 100 feet of mike no offense to mike but im glad bella didnt end up with him i really cant stand mike but i do like him when hes not all wanting to go out with bella when hes "just" her friend.
  • Katiepie
    Bella's proven to be more mature than most teens her age. I would have to agree with Renee, when she says that Bella's never been an ordinary teenager. And personally, I think it'd be better for them to get married with their parents approval, rather than 'forcing' them to elope to Alaska without it. Who knows what ceremonies they'd hold up there with the penguins...
  • daydreamer13
    i have a few things to tell you Katiepie, about alaska. one i live in alaska. two there are no penguines here there in antartica. and if you think that we live in igoloes your plain out stupied. we live in house's just like aneywhere else in the world.
  • ingrid
    Breaking Dawn is the bst book ever cant wait till the movie comes out im crazy for the whole Twilight Saga im obssess with all the books and the movie hope tat thay make more money about all of the books
  • o_0~MeGaN~FaYe~0_o
    Yeah the credit card is actually really cool looking. I don't have one, but I used to work on the rich side of town, and every now and them someone would use theirs...they are heavy, and not nearly as thick as you would think, but they are like ice cold to the touch..... As far as the question goes, I like to think of myself as an open minded person, so I would like to think that if I felt my son our daughter was truly happy, then I could stand behind that.
  • Chelsey
    As always, Kaleb, your posts make me roll laughing.

    I think if I were a parent I would be okay with my daughter getting married that young, especially to someone like Edward. I think everyone, especially Renee and Charlie know that they're in love, and like above posters said, he is the ideal guy- able to provide, polite, well educated, etc. However, if she were marrying Jacob, that would be a different story. Somehow I can't see Renee being okay with her and Jacob, and I don't think Charlie would take it well. Nor would they if she were marrying Mike. However, that does make an interesting* plot for some fanfiction. Which would be rather hilarious, if you think about it.

    *On the grammer fail: It's "a European car" The rule was created to provide better sentence fluency with the transition of vowel sounds. Since "European" has a 'y' sound instead of a typical 'e' vowel sound at the beginning, there is no need to put an "an" in front of it. However, if you were pointing out a letter in a paper, you would say "an N" or "an M" because when you say those letters you make an "e" sound at the beginning. Ah, the glories of English.
  • Sophie
    YouTube won't let me post anything, so I'm posting the video comment here instead. Technology hates me with an everlasting, burning passion. (My friends would back me up on this.)

    I can't wait to read your book!
    Fiction and fantasy are my favorite. Anything like that, really; however, I like In Cold Blood. Then there's Jane Austen and Wuthering Heights. Right now I'm reading The Catcher in the Rye for English, and I love it! It's always exciting when you love a book that's technically considered homework, don't you think?
    Ooo, the ARC talk reminded me of my English class' website (www.not requiredreading.com). Sometimes we get ARC's to review, which is always exciting.
  • Megan
    If I were Bella's parent I would definitely be happy for her if she was marrying Edward. I mean, I know that she is young, but anyone in a 100 mile radius can tell that they're irrevocably in love. On the other hand if she was marrying Mike Newton I would have to go with no.
  • Cara
    Ahahha, Megacat. :)
    I think that I wouldn't be too happy about her getting married so young, though if she were to, I would prefer her being married young to Edward rather than Mike, seeing how he's such a gentleman :)
    Indeed, it is "a European" because its pronounced with a Y sound.
  • chris
    Jacob black is so hot!!!!!serious. but edward is so fucking ugly!!!!!!So true ok those people that like Edward...bella is so fucking white.it looks like she saw a ghost.well again JACOB BLACK IS SOOOOOOOO FUCKING HOT!!!!!!!!!!!
  • kris
    omg, "the megacat"!!!! LMAO
    anyways, no, i wouldn't let my 17 year old daughter get married, no matter who was the groom.....
    ....ok, ok maybe i'd make an exception for someone like Edward, but Mike Newton? NO WAY!!!! LOL
  • Claudia
    OME!!! First of all I'm glad you got to Breaking Dawn finally!!!

    *tears* I remember the time the design of your site used to be Twilight..ok moving on.

    I never gave on thought to Bella's black card and OME!!! Edward is too extravagant, I mean I don't even have one credit card, I mean they won't even approve me for one, but her black little card can probably buy my house with cars and furniture included, ok moving on...

    Yeah I would mind if my 18 yr old child wanted to get married, because she's so young and not experienced in serious adult relationship, even if it was Edward, now me thats a different story I think I could have married Edward at 18 ;)
  • Hélène
    Hello Kaleb!

    I'm 20 years old and I'm french. Your Twilight website is the funniest and the most interesting one I've found on the internet, so congratulation!

    If I were Bella's mother I would really freak out about this wedding! Actually if were Bella I would freak out too... I would never get married until I have a job, my own house and a lot of grown-up stuffs I am not intending to get now!! But that's true, if the groom was Edward, I would think a little bit more about it...

    Thank you very much for your hilarious comments on the twilight books, and please don't mind my english mistakes!
  • I would probably think it was a bit wierd if i would have been Bellas mum but since Edward is freakin' gorgeous I probably wouldn't mind ;) Although I might have been a bit jelous. And Edward is definitly a better choise than Mike ;)
  • Shannah
    Okay... for the rest of Breaking Dawn (When it starts getting bad I mean. And you'll know when it happens) please, please PLEASE do not feel pressured by annoying fangirls to be positive. Bash it is much as you want.
  • Meghan
    P.S. I started laughing EXTREMELY hard at the Megacat thing. I could totally tell that you were a writer when you wrote the whole "they the megacat appears..." section, it sounded EXACTLY like the inside flap of a book.

    P.P.S. The LexKalebCon looks pretty amazing!!
  • Meghan
    Breaking dawn... sigh.
    Stephenie could have made it ten times better. It's not that I don't like it, I do... the plot had so much potential, so much build-up from the first three books and then... boom. crash. hopes-are-destroyed-type music.

    Anyway, to answer the question:

    Well, if Bella was marrying Edward so young and I was her parent, I would first try to steal Edward from her, but after that terrible, terrible attempt, I would be angry. Eighteen is way too young to be married. (However, I think Bella made the right decision due to the circumstances in Twilight, New Moon, and Eclipse, mainly the circumstance dealing with the fact that her love was frozen at the age of seventeen).

    If Bella was marrying Mike Newton, I would be even angrier, because I hate Mike so much...however, it would be quite the funny story...
  • ChelseaLee
    I read "Megacat", I sing "Spaghetti Cat".
  • Bella
    I would have a cow if Bella married Mike... He is a stick in the mud..always do this dont go with him I dont like Cullen... WELL I DO!!! so I wouldnt like if she married Mike...omg thats a good story AU!!! Bella marries mike hahah. ITS AU PEOPLE!! NOT REAL!!!lol
  • Bella
    If I was a parent and my daughter came to me with her boyfriend and sat there and told me she was getting married, I wouldn't mind. I would be proud. If I liked the guy and thought he was good then yes that's a keeper. If she really liked this boy enough to get married then she must have a reason. As long as he wasn't anything like a druh dealer or anything. If she had a good head on her shoulders and he was okay or better than okay then yes I would let them. Give them my blessing. I wouldn't have that big a problem. It's her life and she should be able to live her life the way she wants and spend it with whom ever she wants. I would know this would happen eventually anyway if I was a parent.
  • Crystal
    As a parent, I wouldn't support my daughter making those kind of decisions--let alone this guy being her first boyfriend and all--. But she's eighteen, so it's her decision. If I had known the reason to get married in such a rush, I'd have thought about it more precisely, agreeing at the end. It's her life, not mine.

    It's AN European car.
  • rhiannonanne
    p.s. GREAT song pick!!
  • rhiannonanne
    as a parent, i would not approve of getting married so young. my approach would be to express that opinion clearly (and respectfully) once, then support my daughter in whichever choice she decided to make.

    again, i would let her make her own decision, but inwardly i would always be a little disappointed if she married the newt. he's kind of the ricecake of guys, and bella is clearly anything but average, adequate, or boring.
  • SayuriTeriyaki
    i would let her marry Edward because that´s what will make her happy...aren´t parents supossed to want that??? mmm...about Mike...nope,not at all...he´s just so plain...not the right guy for her...i mean,even if they were a couple it would be obvious that they are not meant to be...
    yay!!! you finally started Breaking Dawn!!! I was so happy when I read this chapter...you know,all the bliss Bella is soaking(haha)and anticipation...
  • Nicole
    Well as a parent I would definately want to know what the rush was all about. Seeing as they both just graduated highschool. However even thought I'd voice my opinion I couldnt force her because she'd before an adult.

    Bella was 18 and there was nothing her parents could really do to stop her from marrying Edward....all you can do for your children after they are 18 is advise, but you cannot coerce. They must live their lives as they see fit and you must trust that you raised them to go right.
  • Rachael
    Ha ha ha! Dr Seuss!
  • I would probably not agree with the marriage but end up agreeing with it.
    because:
    a. it's Edward! He's very mature for his age!
    b. Bella was never really a teen.
    c. it would be a definite no if it was Mike or Jacob

    lol
    Good job and I'll be waiting to hear ch.2!!
    I'm so excited that you're reading Breaking Dawn! Its my favorite one! =D
  • Mattie
    Well, I think i would accept my daughter marrying an Edward beuase he is obviously very mature for his age (figures) and well Bella is hardly the typical teenage girl. it's like what Renee said...she never has been a teenager. And no i would not permit her to marry Mike as well another reason i would accpet Bella marrying Edward is the way they are around each other. it's special. (as renee also said) it's like Bella subcontiously is pulled towards him...even when they ajust movements and it would be quite obvious how much Edward loves her as renee said he looks like he is ready to put himself infront of a bullet to save her. As you can tell i have no copy of the book with me otherwise i'd quote :D I think you wil like Breaking Dawn well at least the middle bit (it's split in 3 parts)...u'll find it very interesting i think :)
  • Rachel
    I'd be dead if I got married that young, no matter who the person was.
    And personally, I don't exactly agree with getting married that young. But in the book's case, it sort of had to be that way.
  • Micky
    Awsome job, finally on breaking dawn, ehh.

    A: If I was bella's parent I would not want her to marry either one, I would make her wait longer before marriage.
    But i'm not bella's mom and this is a fiction book so....
    Marry Edward, Vampires are EPIX~

    Werewolfs.... ehh... they're ok... I guess...?

    By the way loved the gold digger refrence i've considered that lots of times, and I also thought about her and edward if he wasn't a Immortal Vampire God, (Ok i'm exagerating a little) it would'nt be such a love story if he was really 108 years old, but it would add quite a twist!
  • Becky
    Yay! Breaking Dawn!
    "I expect there are plenty of surprises for me in the following chapters"
    AHAHAHA! sorry. couldn't help it, that's just... you will eventually look back on this thought and laugh at how right it was.

    As for your question: I would be skeptical of it. I mean, if my hypothetical 18 year old daughter met a supposedly 17 year old guy and wanted to marry him, I'd probably say they were waaay to young. Regardless of how amazingly hot and rich he may be. And considering that Edward has already left Bella once in their short relationship... I'd be against it.

    But, I'm not a parent, so I can't really say for certain.
  • Polly
    ewwww. can you imagine Jacob in Bella's happy place with Edward? that would be weird.
  • Certifiable TwiMom
    First off kudos to you for picking up on the Centurion Card - I disregarded right away as some fictious creation. I can't believe they are real! Which made me think, wouldn't the townspeople also notice that the Cullens are buying 1/4 million $ worth of stuff every year? I mean there is only a certain amount of stuff you can buy and not be noticed.

    As a mom I wouldn't be happy if my daughter married at 18, but I would support her. Everyone knows that trying to prevent people to do things backfires, so I would try to support her as much as reasonably would be possible. OTOH, I would take her back no problems if it didn't work out. Bella's mom has already pointed out that Bella and Edward have a strangely deep relationship, and I think her mom has basically resigned herself to fate. Can't wait to see what you think of the rest of the book!
  • Maria
    If my 18-year old daughter decided that she wanted to get married I'd seriously consider locking her up like Rapunzel! Even Bella knows that getting married so young is neither wise nor responsible no matter how deep you think your feelings are. Because at 18 you're not nearly mature enough to know what you'll want for the rest of your life!
    But if I could choose between Edward or Mike I'd probably go for Edward because he's more mature, he seems to adore her and, let's face it, he's loaded so at least they won't starve! Ok, now I sound like a gold digger...
  • Susie
    Marrying Mike Newton = epic fail at any age


    If my daughter married Edward...hmm. I'd think she could wait a couple years.
  • response
    to both candidates --> probably not. if they were a bit older, like 20, then I'd be more likely to be okay with it. But ultimately it would be her choice, and if they were sure it was what they really wanted then I'd probably be able to live with it.
  • Katherine M.
    getting married so young - if it makes her happy
    edward - YES!
    mike - not in a million years!
  • Bookflower
    There is no way in which I approve of her getting married so young.
    I'm not actually that old yet, but I definately don't want to get married before I'm finished Uni (or college as you Americans call it). I've seen a lot of relationship break down disarstrously in that period and that, I think it when someone begins to establish themselve as a individual and work out who they truly are, without someone else influencing them. Bella was robbed of this chance - she will develop with Edwrd, just say if something happened to Edward, Bella won't know who she, in herself, was anymore.
    So, no, I wouldn't appprove of her marrying Mike Newtown so young either.
  • Pinky
    Well this was funny....Cant wait for you to read the next few chapters...should be a doosie of a post!!!
  • Poppy
    I Would Be Crushing On Edward If My Daughter Had Descided To Get Married So I Would Be Thinking Grab Him He's A Keeper! And He Would Know So He Might Find That Creepy But He Is Irressitable.

    Anyhoo Yeah i wouldn't Mind With Edward Cause She Really Loves Him And He Too With Her So Yeah I would Be Ok With That :D

    But Uh.... Mike Newton On The Other Hand.. I Dunno He's Cute And All And Funny. But Edward Just Has All The Charms For A Son In Law.

    And Thank You To Your Posts Kaleb This Thing Keeps Me Sane Otherwise There Wouldnt Be Anything Twilight - Books Related To Read - Read All Books A Dozen Times Still Cant Get Enough!

    Bye Kaleb xx Enjoy New Moon I Did!
  • Mmary
    Note to Stephenie: it was my idea first. Hands off.

    lololol!

    And, yeah, I think there was somethin different about Bella and Edward that even Charlie noticed, so that's why he let them get married.
  • First of all, thanks for your great website, it's a real treat for someone like me who is looking for a little Twilight fix to fill in the empty spaces.

    As for your question... I don't think Charlie's reaction in the book is really all that unrealistic. First of all, I think parents are willing to be much more supportive than we give them credit for, especially when their kids seem happy. I can't imagine that Charlie is completely surprised about the announcement, given his little speech in Eclipse about having a feeling he would be losing Bella soon. I think Charlie is very likely to accept the decisions Bella makes - it seems to me that he already sees her as an adult, because he lets her do all the shopping, cooking, and cleaning in the house. Whether or not he likes Edward, I think he has seen that Bella can't be without Edward. He probably knows as well as anyone.

    As for Mike Newton? I don't know. As a parent, I don't think I'd want my daughter to settle for the nice, normal guy. I think I'd want spectacular things for my child, a dazzling, passionate, challenging man - not a boring one.
  • God, how many comments in such little time! lol

    Wow, I can't believe you've started already! Really, you have me completely addicted to your blogs. When I saw you had updated, I even laughed out loud. I was so excited!

    Well, let's talk about what you wrote. I wouldn't be happy if my daughter wanted to get married at 18. I wouldn't agree with that. But, they can't really stop her since she's 18, so I guess they don't want to fight her and spoil their relationship with Bella when they know it will be useless.

    About Jacob, well... You'll see. ;)

    There was one thing that touched me in this chapter. It was Charlie's worry for Jacob. We have to remember that he's been friend with Billy since forever, so he's seen Jacob grow up. I think he loves him as an uncle or something like that. It's touching.

    I'll be waiting for your next update!
  • dee
    if i were Bella's parent I would not have agreed. She's too young.
  • Margie
    I would be very upset if my child was getting married at 18! However, I would try to be sympathetic and listen and trust because my husband and I fell in love at 19 and have now been married for 7 years and together for 12.
  • devz30
    parenting questions while I'm still 15? lol. OK, I'll answer.
    In a parent's pov, think it would be ok if Bella married young if I knew Edward well.... And trust him, I guess.
    ... and Mike Newton? If Bella loved him and if I think they'll be happy, then why not? After all, who is to tell who their 'edward' is in their lives? ^^
  • Jadie
    lol, awesome song choice! It totally fits this chapter!

    Hmmm....I'd have to say NO to Mike Newton. He's not near mature enough to be married yet, seriously.

    Maybe Edward, just because he is such a gentleman, and seems mature enough. although, then again, 18 is a little too young to be married. so I'm not sure on that one.

    It's probably "a European" because 'y' is only sometimes used as a vowel.

    I can't wait to read your thoughts on the rest of the book!!
  • Anonymous
    This is just my theory but I would say a European because it starts with a 'y' sound
  • Laura
    Heather: “Have You Seen This Boy Who Was Close To Bella Then Suddenly Disappeared Soon After The Cullens Returned Recently Sporting Some Serious Injuries.” hahaha
  • Laura
    Yay finally Kaleb!! I'm so looking forward for you to keep reading... I wouldn't be very happy that my 18 year old daughter was getting married, even less if it was to Mike Newton (lol that was random). I won't spoil anything but if like me, you feel that a lot has change just by the first chapter, just wait until you're further in the book, it's crazy. I can't believe that you didn't mention the monster passing away!!! I couldn't believe it... and Edward could've picked a car just a tiny bit less notorious.. loved the photos:)and surprises in the following chapters? you have no idea... Jacob's missing is heartbreaking...next chapter is really good though there's like 2 different feelings to it, u'll get it (and I can predict a few things you will talk about;) )
  • courtney
    Lol. I thought the drug lord thing was hilarious and the fact that jacob left broke my heart. To answer your questions, i would be happy if my child were marrying young. I only say this because 1. she has been with him for how many years now???? 2. she is completely head over heals i love with him (if you were arould her you would probably be stupid not to notice). I would only want what makes her happy. Better him (a gentlemen) than Mike (a young kid with a crazy stupid agenda)!!!
  • Yeah I think it's a European car. :) Not an because if you say it out loud it sounds kinda funny, dontcha think? ;)
  • BTW, MegaCat, I luvz it. Does Ceiling Cat know?
  • At this point, at age 24, I still get cold feet. Maybe that's why I still don't have a boyfriend. In real life I would not approve of Bells marrying at 18. There is so much growing up to do first. Even if I knew the guy was a forever-17 vampire, she will still look young at 21 and can wait till then. But don't worry, the age differences are even more bizarre in the Host.
  • can i just say that comment #9 ,theholythief was absoultely amazing?
    and it'll be called Twisted Nation.
    :D
  • Yesenia
    OMG YOU INALLY GOT TO BREAKING DAWN! WOOO! lol...
    good research right there Kaleb...thats a true lit critter. heheh.
    hmmm...id think bella was getting married way to young. i mean, before, i used to be all like, "awww highschool sweethearts getting married" like as soon as theyre out of school, but the other day i as thinking to myself, that is way too young. like, not many people take things serious at that age. so if i was bella's parent, thats where my mind would be.
    but if she was marrying mike newton... oh lordy...idk lol.
  • courtney
    If you're a huge fan, why did you wait so long to read Breaking Dawn? Hasn't the wait been unbearable?
  • FabiolaBlack
    well
    if I were bella's mother and my daugher was about to get married to Edward Cullen i think i would try to sabotage the wedding and kiddnap edward so he can marry me instead of my daughter...
    ok just kidding i may not be really happy but agree at the end
  • NancyB
    As a mother, I would LOVE to see my daughter marry someone as hawt and rich as Edward Cullen. Mike who???
  • Wendy
    Took you long enough to get here. Just kidding. If I were Bella's parents I would be upset but Edward can be very charming and if it was Mike I would say to wait a little bit longer.
  • Carrie
    I wouldn't be very happy about my 18 year-old daughter getting married, but I guess her mom can see that she is very much in love and she is an adult now. It didn't even occur to me that the police would be blaming Edward for Jacob's disappearance. I thought it seemed obvious that Jacob ran away because he was upset over the wedding.
  • I wouldn't mind the marrying Edward part but mostly because Bella does seem very mature and Edward is a gentleman and has, even after the leaving thing, proven that he lives and dies (pardon the pun) for Bella. Mike? Nope, he's not the same caliber of man.
  • Jenny
    Just so you know, Kaleb, you will have
    A LOT of surprises in store for you. As for you're question, I think I wouldn't be upset if Bella got married to Edward, as long as I got to know him and if she really loved him, which she does. As for Mike Newton, the same principles apply. =D
  • No, it's not a grammer fail. "European car" is correct because 'European' is acting as a proper adjective (modifying 'car') and all proper adjectives are capitalized.
  • lauren
    I would be happy even if it was Mike Newton. The only reason is because if she's was happy than I would be happy for her (even if I wasn't happy).
  • maggie
    Oh, right, and I just remembered about the driving thing: I got you beat, Kaleb!! Not sure how it is in other states, but here in NC, you have to be behind the wheel for 6 hours with an instructor riding shotgun before you can get your permit. This is the first time I've ever driven. I pull out of the parking lot and SPLAT! I hit a squirrel. Seriously, the first thing I ever did behind the wheel of a car. I was traumatized, and I hate driving to this very day...
  • maggie
    I think that, not even counting what all the non-hmans know, if I were Charlie or Renee, I would wish she would wait a bit longer, but I would let her. I would see that they were going to be able to work it out. As for Mikey... well, I don't think people are very nice to Mike! He catches a lot of crap, just because he isn't a supernatural being! He can't help it, so BACK OFF AND BE NICE!!! Plus, if there was no Edward or Jacob, she so would have fallen for Mikey... but, no, I wouldn't let Bella marry him just out of school. My parents married at 19, and they lasted 11 years, but they shouldn't have been married so young, because they were really just kids. That's the difference with Edward and Bella. Even those who don't know that hes 110 years old are able to tell that he isn't really a kid, and even though Bella's only 18, she's not really a kid either...
    That's the condensed verion of my thoughts... I'm so glad you've started Breaking Dawn, its my second favorite (the first being Twilight)!
    xo
    ~M
    ps: sorry for rambling :) :)
  • Samantha
    jw, i can't seem to find the links to read your reviews for the rest of the series..knowing me it's probably right in plain sight..but anyway i hadn't finished reading those so i thought i'd ask!
    oh and i'm super happy you started reading bd! it was my second favorite of the series :)
  • Chloe Cullen
    With Bella getting married to Edward, I think that I would feel like Bella was too young but like I could be happy with that choice. Neither of them is what anyone would call ordinary, and they are both very mature and quite obviously truly in love.

    On the other hand, if Bella was getting married to Mike I would seriously suspect what Bella fears that others think about her and Edward's early marriage ;)
  • Melanie
    I enjoy the thought of you in the middle of an intersection in your grandmother's car. It makes me feel less stupid about driving as a I just started yesterday and got made fun of at school by friends because my father and I spent an hour and a half driving around a huge school parking lot and doing laps around the school. So anyway thank you for that.
    If I were Bella's parents I would hope I would be observant enough to see how well Edward and Bella work together. Though I would be frightened by marriage so young, I think I would have to understand and trust Bella, who is honestly a pretty sensible girl.
    Mike Newton could be thought of as a completely different situation. The same trust would have to apply, yet to see Bella with someone who she obviously wasn't intertwined souls with, I do not believe I would be happy that she would be marrying him.
    Hope that makes some sense.....
    Also kudos to having started Breaking Dawn :) yay for new beginnings!!
  • Tina
    1. If I was Bellas Mother I would see that Edward makes her happy. I wouldn't mind her marrying young, if she is happy with him I wouldn't want to stand in the way. Plus Bella was at the legal age of 18 when she got married, she was out of high school, and She was planning on still attending college. If I saw that I wouldn't stand in the way. Sometimes you have to let them go and do what they want. Bella was always happy with him around. and Bellas parents see it, of how happy she is with him.

    2. I cannot see Bella with Mike at all. She always seemed she wanted to be his friend nothing more. So no I could never see them married. even though Mike would love to be married to her lol, it will never happen.

    3. But think about this

    What if Bella Was with Jacob?
    What if Bella Married Jacob & not edward??
    How will Bellas life be with Jacob??
  • Maddie
    Just a warning: You're probably going to hate this book. I did.
  • Mariana
    oh, and I would not be okay with it. Especially not when I made the mistake. But, as Bella has pointed out, she is of age, and I as a parent wouldn't really be able to do anything about her getting married.
  • Mariana
    oh my gosh I saw cat at first too!!!
    I, however, did not think of MegaCat. I had this weird thought process. In my imagination, the cat morphed into a wolf. And that wolf was Jacob. And he was following Bella around. And I started cracking up, because I had a picture of a giant wolf following a ridiculous giant car around the empty streets of Forks. :D
  • Megan
    If I was Bella's parent I'd want her to wait a few years until she's at least finished college. I wouldn't mind though because I knew that marriage wouldn't change much for them, they loved each other and were already planning on living together, so why not get married?

    If it was Mike Newton? Um...If she loved him as much as she loves Edward it would be fine...Funny...but fine;p
  • D.Y.E.
    Yayyyyy! You finally made it to BD! I've been very deprived of your posts for the last like two weeks, and this one is like a breath of fresh air!

    I can't wait till you finish!
  • Michelle C.
    If I were Bella Swan's mother...I would allow her to get married. True love is a strong abstract, and this is just one of the things that a parent can't give her. But, parents allow their children/teens happiness, right? Well, she's happy with Eddie, so, yeah. I don't even think eight-teen is that young. Plus, eight-teen is the age you start taking control of your life & deciding yourself.

    I don't really believe in true love for me, because of my complications & marridge is a STRONG commitment. I'd write a novel of this..but, i dont wanna take it out on Kale's fans.

    CONGRATZ KALE! This is a amazing book! My 2nd favorite.
  • Jen
    Kaleb, for some strange reason the first chapter's analysis of each 4 books has always been my favorite, especially eclipse's first chapter. I don't know what it is but I just love the first chapters. Not the chapters themselves, just your take on it. Anyway, thanks for another great chapter. Just an idea, I think it would be great if, at the end, you would make a wall of fame and have viewers vote on their favorite chapters that you wrote about. Just an idea. :)
  • Nadia
    I would certainly not want her getting married, she is too young even if it is her 'soul-mate' I would insist on the college education being completed first.

    Also like Charlie I would prefer she dated Jacob for a couple of years and then get married. - the long distance relationship while she was in college would be no prob for jake with the speed he runs.
  • Kylie
    WOOOOO BREAKING DAWN!!!!! I'm so happy you're reading this now.
    Megacat made me laugh so hard!

    Btw I'm pretty sure it's A European car because it has a "Y" sound at the beginning instead of a vowel sound. So yes you are right :D
  • Natalie
    As a parent, I wold be fine with Mike Newton. But from Charlie's point of view, Edward is bad for her. He has put her through a lot and she has basically gone crazy and catatonic because of him. And now she wants to marry him??... What is she, nuts?!

    haha. I'm an Edward fan, but I can't blame Charlie for disliking him. Still, he realizes it's not his place to tell her who she can marry. Poor Charlie.
  • Heather
    hmm.. it probably would depend on what the girl were like. ya know?
    if she were as responsible and level-headed as Bella, then i might just approve of such a crazy event (although, i myself would never think of doing such a thing!).
    And Edward is WAYY into Bella. Anybody can see that. He's too devoted to doubt.
    Mike Newton, on the other hand, seems just like any other teenage boy, so i probably wouldn't approve of him at all..
    Then again, i'm very biased. =)
  • Anna_Loves_TWILIGHT
    YAY!!!! Kaleb's reading Breaking Dawn. I really love this book, it has so many unexpected twists and a bunch of things you wouldnt have thought possible.

    I would just like to let you know, Kaleb, that if Breaking Dawn takes place in the year I think it does, Edward would be 105 years old at that point. Right now he is 107 1/2.

    If I was Bella's mom, and she told me she was marrying Edward, I would not have been surprised. I would also not have been angry. She is a very mature person, and even though they havent even known each other for 2 years (can you believe it?) it is clear even to an oblivious-of-vampires human that they have been through alot in a short time. Mike: I would have been shocked. The first words out of my mouth would have been "You Hardly Know Him!!!". I would definetely tell her to wait on Mike, it is clear they dont have much of a bond.

    The correct grammar is A European Car.

    Has anyone else noticed that everysingle comment was labeled 1? or is that my suckish computer??
  • Vanessa
    I'm so excited about you reading breaking dawn! :D LOL.

    I think I wouldn't like it if my daughter wanted to get married at 18. She's really young.
    But this is a fictional book, and there are plenty of reasons of why getting married is really important for them.

    And if she wanted to marry Mike, I wouldn't like it either. As I said, she's young, and she's starting to live. I think getting married that early is dumb, because you just became an adult, you're just starting your life, you're just entering the world.

    Again, I'm really excited about you reading BD!!! But it makes me feel sad, everytime I realize this is the last book :(
  • Mylles
    AHHHH!! breaking dawn!! :D finallY! anyway, if my daughter were getting married at age eighteen to anyone i would probably be freaking out. i mean seriously, scary thought. and it would be creepy if that guy were say a vampire! interesting thought. but i think Renee saw this one coming. in fact she says she did so i think i would have a better hold on myself like she does. and if Bella married Mike Newton i think Jess would be so pissed off, which would be hilarious but i still think i would react the sam eso why not Bella's parents
  • Rian
    First off i'm almost 22 and i think that that is still too young to get married in the real world, but this is fiction so i'm okay with it.

    As for Charlie, i expected a bigger reaction from him, but i don't think he want's to be on Bella's bad side. He knows at any time she could just disappear and he knows she would be with Edward. I also thought Renee would have a hissy-fit.

    Yay! I'm so happy that you started on Breaking Dawn! It's my favorite and i can't wait to hear all of your insights!
  • janeth
    teenage daughter getting married?
    uh - no. Not if we're talking about MY teenage daughter.
    Bella? yeah. ok. As her mom said, Bella is an old soul and she has found another old soul to love. If her mom thinks it will be ok, then I do.
    - " a care made in Europe." ??
    - thanks for the info on AMX Centurion cards. Had no idea. But then again, why would I?
    snort.
    I'm excited about you're getting into the last book.
    And nervous about what we'll do when you finish.
    I mean, besides all flock to your Kaleb Nation web/blog site. I've so enjoyed your comments and observations on these books!
  • tina
    Yay!! Kaleb is reading Breaking Dawn!!! I'm excited to see what you think!! Glad I checked today.

    Your question - Well, I am a mother. My oldest is 19. There comes a point when you realize that your children need to make their own choices, and that you can't be in control of their lives as they get older. If my son came to me and said he was getting married, I would sit down with both of them and talk - about reality...the cost of living, what their plans are for college, etc. But, when it comes right down to it, I'd support them and love them, even if they don't make the choice I would like them to make.

    It's not easy to be a parent!! ;)

    By the way, I started dating my hub when I was 18, we got married at 21 and have been married for 21 years. It is possible for relationships like ours to work!!
  • Paige
    Oh Kaleb, you never fail to crack me up! Congrats on your book! I shall keep an eye out for it! What types of books do I like? Hmm... not really sure. I have pretty diverse taste in books, but at the same time I'm kinda picky. I suppose I like anything somewhat similar to Twilight. LOL! Thanks for the little lesson on what they do with your book before it gets published. I'm an aspiring writer myself, but so far I've been sticking to fanfics. I probably won't be able to start my own novels till I get my own laptop.
    Anywho...
    Now unto the Twilight question. If I was Rene or Charlie, I probably wouldn't have any objection to Bella marrying Edward. Maily cuz I would be able to see how much they truly love each other. A love like that deserves to last. Now if it was Mike, I dunno. I'd probably say no! LOL! Mike's okay, he's just kinda of a pest.
  • jenb
    I was really surprised at how easily Charlie & Renee took the news that she was going to marry Edward. I was glad though so that it could all work out and Bella could start living her life w/her soul mate and the wonderful Edward.

    Now to your questions. If I was Bella's parents I would probably not be mad but would want her to wait. (They get engaged & married in like what 3 months?)But then again Bella has always been very mature for her age and Edward is a gentlmen. As for Mike (interesting question) I don't think I would be as cool. He's just a immature teenage boy who doesn't think of Bella as more than a pretty face & the new girl he was hoping to "get"
  • Taylor
    If I was Bella's mom, and I knew she was marrying Edward...well, I'd probably find a way to sabotage the wedding, give Edward a love potion, and then he'd marry me! =)
  • Victoria
    Yea finally! I was so happy when I saw that you posted! I love the whole credit card thing! That was so funny, "Since no one is curious, I won’t post any photos".
    Know to answer your question, I wouldn't be mad at Bella for marrying Edward. I would tell her though to wait a while longer. Edward is a wonderful man! Edward has proven himself to be a responsible and respectful person. I would definitely have to side with Renee and what she said to Bella about her getting married to Edward.
    On the other hand, if she was getting married to Mike Newton, I would infinitely disapprove! Mike is not like Edward! Edward is a gentleman with manners. He also has years and years worth of knowledge (not that any other human, but Bella, knows that fact). Mike is just a young hormonal teenager, who can't help but think dirty thoughts about Bella. He's to immature.
    ~One thing that I love about this chapter is how Charlie freaks out when Edward tells him that they are getting married! That was the funniest thing ever!!
    *Victoria
  • annab
    I've been waiting for you to read this chapter forever. you probably don't remember my comment from when you were reading the first book but that's okay.. I wouldn't either. But when you said Bella's truck reminded you of a fire truck I commented on how I thought Bella's truck actually paralleled Edward in many ways and probably even symbolized him.
    .. I read the beginning of Breaking Dawn like a month or so before it came out or whatever. Me being a literary dork and finding comparisons i found the loss of the truck to be a VERY bad thing. I thought it could mean a couple things
    1. I could be completely off and there is a coincidence of a parallel but no real symbolism.
    2. truck does = edward and something happens to him
    3. truck does = edward and Bella doesn't need him anymore or something.? (it's been awhile since i was thinking of outcomes)

    So yes I had to go about a month with the loss of a symbolism of a main character and thought the worse.... I wonder what you think.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Not responsible for ad content